A friend of mine brought up a discussion on an Army Wives FB page asking for opinions about fairness of child support that men have to pay. I thought it was an interesting topic and was wondering what you ladies and gents if your out there thought about it. I know some men have to pay upwards of about $400 a month in child support. How would you feel if your current husband had to pay that much to an ex who is working possibly re-married while you and and him also have other children to support? My personal situation is that my oldest has had no contact with her dad since she was 4 years old and we plan to keep it that way. He is just a bad guy. He owes her over $11,000 in child support but I let it go because it is worth it to not have him doing damage in her life. I wonder how much you all think is reasonable per month to recieve in child support? I know most women have to do what they have to do to make sure their kids are taken care of in situations like this, but do you think it is fair to take away from other kids in the situation by accepting a large amount of monthly child support? I am not taking any sides I am just curious as to what you all think.
Iv never been in this type of situation but the way I see it if a judge says that's what they owe then so be it. They go based on income right so i think $400 or more is fair. If the woman gets remarried and is working what's it matter? Her new man shouldn't be financially responsible for another mans child. That's just my opinion though.
judges take into consideration other children in the equation. I have a friend who has 4 kids by 3 different women, he pays child support to all of them, but once his last one was born, the support went down to allow for his newest to have some money too. He is living with the mom of 2 of his kids.
i actually had legal guardians when my parents died and they had ledgers of all the money they spent on me and my brother. they actually had an alloted amount. and when it comes down to it.... 400 (tech 800, both parents) it barely gets you by. We each were alloted about 1200 hundred and it was divided between the whole household... kinda like a roommate type situation.
and it covered it at first... but think as the child gets older and school shopping, braces, unforseen accidents, dr visits, health problems... i mean the tab adds up..
I am NOT a parent but plenty of people around me have children and i love the idea of children. Im just not ready to have them yet.
I am a very firm believer in tradition and i think that if you cant really pay for the child... you shouldnt be allowed to 'spread that seed' lol!
so to answer your question... i think 400 is a little low... but do-able :)
The Judge awarded my daughter $131 a month because her dad was just getting out of the Marines and didn't have a job yet. That was the minimum you could pay in Arizona. I think it is a little unrealistic these days with the economy the way it is. I do not think one parent should have to bare the majority of a child's expenses unless they choose to. When a married couple has a house payment, childcare expenses, car note, insurance, food, gas, utilities,and incidentals .. most people are barely able to make those ends meet let alone shoveling out an extra 400 in child support. I hear women talk about monthly clothing costs and what not.. My kids do not get new clothes every month.
It was stated that the new spouse should not be have to financially support a child that isn't theirs. I think that when two people get married and blend a family then the new husband should take some financial responsibility for his new family his kid or not. That is like saying I am going to feed you and my kid but that kid that isn't mine will have to go without unless her dad pays for it. My husband and I have been supporting my oldest daughter since she was in kindergarden. He has never complained about it.
Don't get me wrong.. I think both parents should have to support their children. My brother and his GF share custody of their son. He has to pay $231 in child support even tho he lives with him 50% of the time pays half of his daycare costs, buys his clothes and diapers, and never collects the EIC come tax time. I think sometimes the dads who are trying to do right get screwed over.
SKay, I think you are right. It is usually the dads who are trying that get screwed over. Look at my situation. My husband has taken on my older ones and of course, they call him dad, but the real one just got away without doing anything, but he helped make them while we were married. It is really sad how it works out sometimes. We have always done whatever we have to for all of them regardless if the child support comes or not. Now, he gets to do as he pleases and everything without ever seeing them, not going to rehab, no other children to take care of and the stinkin money he sent them for Christmas BOUNCED!!!!! So, I think if the children live with both parents 50% of the time, then they are both taking half of the responsibility. He shouldn't be paying child support in that situation. Crazy!!
My ex is supposed to pay a measly $250 a month for one child while I hold all other responsibilities like medical, dental. He does not pay it. He has paid $1,000 toward child support in 3 years. He's an alcoholic. :(
The father of my son pays child support. I didn't even request it. The army told him when we divorced what he had to pay and that was it. They ordered him to pay 620 a month. It was based on his bah he was getting but was still living in the barracks. I agreed for him to pay an extremely lower amount so he could get his own place and take his child on weekends and be able to see him. Needless to say he never did, nor does he call to ask about him or anything. He's seen him for a total of 5 minutes in the past 9 months and he lives literally a min drive from us. He thinks his online girlfriend is more important. So therefore I told him that he can pay the full amount what they ordered.
I think that should be no more than maybe 250 to 300 per child but shared daycare, health and dental bills. I also think that if the custodial parent marries the child support should be revised because there is another income. I understand that the new husband shouldn't be responsible for supporting the child fully,BUTTTTTT, he knows what he is getting into when he marries a single parent, it's a package thing. And no, I have never been in this situation. For a while we were about to be but I wasn't going to take my husband to the cleaners. As much as I want to be financially secure, I wanted him to have something to offer when the kids were w/him instead of an empty 1 bdrm apartment cause that's all he could afford.
Now in Megan's case I do agree, if you are not going to spend ANY money on the kids for lack of involvement, screw it, make child support higher so the kids can have a good life in the one home they have
My son who is 17 get a measly 200 a month and it only gets it spordacially. (sp)Hw is 17 and if we depeneded on child support he would starve or not be clothed. He has 4 other children.
my husband pays child support every month. He has paid over 20000 in the last 2 yrs. I have a problem with moms who dont use the money for what it is for. 2 new cars in 2 yrs is not what child support is for, 2 iphones is not what child support is for. When the child calls and says dad i need school clothes but yet we pay child support each month.. you know the mom is not spending it on what it should be spent on. there are dads that try... dads that want to be there.. dads that are pissed off that the system doesnt care. That the mom doesnt want anything but that mighty dollar..
the mom doesnt work.. she lives on our child support. and her new fiance.
Wow well my sons father is behind and i could say well he is behind you are not getting it. Its like a surprise when he gets it and he spends it wisely. Some mother s do that spend it only for themsleves. I have not even had a new car in 2 years wow. It is sad for dads that do their part it makes the good dads look bad.
Crystal I have heard about a lot of women who do not spend the money responsibly... If I were to ever get a dime from my ex which I could care less a bout.. it would go straight into an account for her for after high school.. I keep thinking I am cheating her out of some good money for school and a car and whatnot for when she goes to college by not going after it, but at the same time, I don't want to have to start shipping her to see him when he is a drug addict who just got out of prison has two other kids and she is now 13 and hasn't seen him since she was 4. What sense would that make?
Sounds like I have great taste in men huh... Background.. I got pregnant with my oldest when I was 15 and had her 13 days after I turned 16. Got married when I was 17 and he joined the Marines. There was no one to say no you can't do this your too young. I wish I had someone that had done that for me but it all worked out in the end. When he got out of the marines he lost his damn mind. Started doing hard drugs and went to prison for possession, selling, and burglery all happend after our divorce was final. I just have no desire for her to have anything to do with him.
I don't expect money for my daughter, she lives with me half the year and her dad half the year. The economy is bad where he is at so if times are hard I go get her. We didn't have a big nasty divorce and we don't hate each other. I really hate the moms who only want full custody so they can get money! Even if I had full custody I wouldnt expect or ask for money from her dad. If I can't afford a child w/out help maybe I shouldn't of had kids...thankfully that's not an issue.
we have tried to put insurance on his daughter but the mom wont let us.. she doesnt want to lose state assistance. we are officially paid off on child support. we know the mom is after the mighty dollar cause she called and asked if she was getting our taxes..
We would have loved to be able to put all the money in a bank account for her so she can go to college but the mom wanted to spend it.. she told my husband to get out of the army and to tell the army no he wasnt moving.. anyways.. sorry to vent but sometimes there are dads that try and do want to be there... his daughter has 2 siblings we would love for her to know.. but the mom doesnt want to cooperate.
Okay, I read the comments and I have feeling on both sides. I am a divorced woman who has been ordered to receive child support from my ex husband. Like one of you mentioned, in order to get a divorce I had to include child support in the divorce decree because it was not optional. I elected to receive $200.00 a month because I just knew he wasn't gonna pay it. Long story short, he got chaptered out of the Army and will probably never ever get a decent job. I asked the court that it be deposited into a checking account with my daughter's name on it because I did not want to have to go back to court every time he missed a payment ( which he has missed every single payment since our divorce). As a custodial parent, I am expected to clothe, feed, shelter, insure, and etc. my daughter regardless as to whether I get child support or not. People are really quick to judge the mother's whom their husbands or boyfriends are paying child support to. Yes, I live in a decent home, yes I drive a newer decent car, I have an iPhone and so on. I was able to acquire these things and maintain them after I got rid of dead weight and minus his support, so obviously I don't need his child support to get them in the first place. I see people all over complaining about how the Mom is living good and remarried and THEY are struggling. Well, while my EX was bashing me, I was sitting in a class 9.5 hrs a day busting my butt to get my second degree while going through a terrible divorce. I worked hard to prepare myself for what was to come and it paid off, so now his girlfriend who choses to not do the same complains because he is ordered to pay child support to his daughters--(He has another daughter and as long as we were married, he never ever missed a child support payment to that child. I ensured that because that is the type of woman I am. And, he was ordered to pay $792 a month.) She is now reconsidering because she is pregnant and he has yet to do anything for her or that baby. I asked any woman who is with a man to not rant about his OBLIGATIONS. You may not agree because he is your only source of income, but these are things that you should have considered before deciding to be with him. And, if your income taxes are being garnished for child support payments and you're upset over that, it speaks a lot of you. First of all, as a woman, I would not be in a relationship with a man who is not taking care of his child in the first place. I have a fiance who pays child support and he has never been behind. If his daughter calls and asks for something, I don't hinder him from doing for her. If you are a Mom in my shoes, I commend you. If you are a women having to deal with this situation in your home and you're ensuring that it is being done, I commend you. If he's not paying, don't bother and don't let others know your ignorance. Why should he take care of the kids he have with you and not the others????
Happy in Wash.. I think it is a little unfair to say that people should have considered the type of man they are with before they get into the relationship. Alot of times things happen and people change. Did I think my husband who was in the Marines was going to turn into a crack head drug dealing theif? I don't think I would have married him had I known that was where he was heading. A man or woman who has kids should do everything within their power to support them. Unfortunatly too many adults let their petty sh*t run the show and the kids end up getting used as tools to jab at one another..
I think you totally misunderstood what I was saying that comment for. If that was the case, it would certainly be applicable to me because I was like you and I ended up getting screwed when I did the right thing. I never thought my husband would be physically abusive and neglectful in the end of our marriage, yet he was. I stated that in reference to the women who knew that their husbands had child support obligations and/or kids from prior relationships to take care of and yet they still feel he should not take responsibility for those kids because it causes hardship on them. We can't help how people turn out. We are only accountable for self.
Did not read everything above...but my husband used to pay 479 a month for my stepson...it was BS because she was voluntarily unemployed...in other words, and straight from her mouth, she was too good to work and wanted his money. Because of that, he had to pay more...we could not get it changed until later on...which we could have since he had us and more kids. We ended up getting full custody of my stepson and the state decided that even thou she chooses not to work, they say she can....so they awarded my husband 358 a month from her...and of course we have not seen a penny of it....she is already over 4,000 behind.
Oh, my ex only pays 100 every other friday for my daughter...its what we agreed on because I get to claim her every year on taxes and he has to pay all travel expenses to and from Lousiana over the summer.
Oh, and she was supposed to be responsible for her own medical and dental coverage for my stepson...well, she decided to go get him dental work done with no insurance and tried having the $500 bill sent to us...we sent it back...well, then he gets a call from child support saying he has to pay it...he told them that its not his responsibility, and if they would look at the paperwork they would know that....it was their response that killed us..."well, why dont you just pay it anyways....thats how it usually goes"....really?? Its fustrating because they didnt wanna follow the paperwork that mom signed and agreed too!!! We never had to pay it...but sheesh.
Wow, I'm sorry, to hear that, but at least you have custody and the bright side is your willingness to step in and be a Mom to him.I hear my friends complaining about $500 child support that their spouses are paying and that he is not able to take care of their family. If he is ordered to pay that amount, that is what the state has deemed him able to pay. Some of us are just nice about it and want to move on with our lives. I never once complained and my Ex husband was eventually ordered to pay $792 a month from the state of NC. I always knew he had that child and I could deal with it or go. He willfully paid that but complained and he complains about the $200 he is ordered to pay me because he has since had 2 more kids. Some woman will still get with him knowing that he has 4 different kids with 4 different women and she will go and complain about child support. Seriously, what can he offer her. Anyone with him should expect that as a way of life. The decision to become a parent is always a hard one, but ultimately in the end it is the responsibility of two individuals, not one. I know sometimes it seems unfair and some people won't understand until the shoe is on the other foot and by they they are like oh I see. When it's their child not being supported then attitudes begin to shift. My Ex lives in GA and even though he hasn't sent a dime in over 2 years he still complains that I should be responsible for getting her to him because I chose to move cross country. He is delusional. We resided in El Paso and after he chose to get kicked out of the Army and became a classified stalker, I had every right to go where ever.
I totally get it...I am in those shoes since I get child support from my ex and its barely anything...and I get that my husband had to support his son...it just irks me that she was that way about getting a job...she seriously told the lawyers she was too good to work and wanted more money from my husband...of course...she is also crazy...seriously...its one of the many reasons we got custody...it took us 5 years trying to get him away from her...she is a horrible person and he deserved better
I know there are many women like that and that part is so unfair. My ex's other daughter's mom never wanted to work either, which is why CS was so much. Finally after she complained about my daughter being in private school and every other pettiness she could muster up, I told her that if she worked and provided her part, life would get better for her. That was in June 2007 and by December 2007 she got her degree and a teaching job. Didn't keep it long, but it helped. The icing was when I took my step daughter shopping for school and got her 15 outfits, dresses for church, shoes, school supplies and everything else, and her mom kindly reminded me that there were 30 days in a month, not 15. (I did all of this on top of almost $800 in CS.) I then told her that I realized there were 30 days in a month , however, there are 2 parents per child. Being that he had already purchased 15 outfits, the only thing left for her to do was to buy her half, the other 15 outfits. Ungrateful.
My husbands ex is an e6 now and my hubby is an e5, she makes more obviously. she expected my husband to not only pay 500 a month for their son together but for her daughter from a previous marriage before she met my husband. She made my husband feel obligated to take care of both. Anywho, my hsuband by law pays 500 a mth which i think is a lot. She doesnt allow my husband to talk their son but expects tons and tons from him like extra money, gifts, etc. The few times in the past year we HAVE had him he is in ragidy clothing, shoes too small, underwear tooooo tiny, borrowing neighbors clothes...bushy hair, my husband is like WTF??? So he spends HUNDREDS, YES HUNDREDS on new shoes and clothing...then we never see him in those clothes ever again, we get him again and he's in ragidy borrowed clothes AGAIN!! And she's married but before i met my hubby she was going behind her husbands back asking my husband for help with rent. uhm....you get double BAH cause her new man is army also....you get 500 in child support and your kid looks poor and you cant pay rent!?!? Im so annoyed. she tried suckering me into giving her 700 a mth when my hubby deployed but i laughed and said HELL no. she ever since has been a heathen and a biotch towards us all. she is money hungry for surrrrrrrrree
I am now married and understand both sides. My husband has taken of my son from day 1 and does treat him any diffrent. My son father has nothing to do with him and pays a measly 215 a month we do not get it hes owes a lot of back pay. He has over children and 2 other baby mamas. A lot of woman step up and be a mother to that child. As saying you should have taken into consideration what you married people changed and sometimes for the worse not the better. My sons father is a peice of s### he ask to give up rights when he was 15 beause he no longer wanted to support him you do not now so what. Children are not cheap and mothers/fathers need to step up.