Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Breastfeeding

who's talking here?

wildflower2007 3
JustcallmeSuz 1
ShamWow 2
R 1
Katena 1
Sandra 4
Megan LeeAnne 1
Maui Girl 1
staindingbymyman 7
MASC 2
Leesah 5
Shelley S 1
ella ella 1
details 4
myopinion 1
AwesomeSauce 4
camoworld 1
Pepper 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

camoworld --- 14 years ago -

http://shine.yahoo.com/parenting/time-magazines-breastfeeding-cover-moms-react-185700989.html



Hmmm....everyones entitled to there own opinion on what they choose to do...however.....4 years old?? NOOOOOO WAAAYYYYY! 

wildflower2007 --- 14 years ago -

im more disturbed by the title of that article..."are you mom enough?"...

...the media needs to stay out of mothering issues like this, instead of inflaming them...

i dont think anyone wins with an article like that, or a picture like that:

--Women who breastfeed long-term and AP are seen as this woman is--she looks like she's daring someone to say something so she can rip their head off or something...

--Women who don't do that are implied as being "not mom enough", like this is something they should do, even though it's not the choice they've made for their family or parenting...

it's an ignorant article meant to ruffle feathers, sell magazines, and inflame a debate that's inflamed enough. 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

I think when a kid gets teeth, it's time to stop the boob. My cousins son at the age of 3 used to walk up to his mom no matter where they were or what they were doing and breastfeed. When a child is old enough to chew their food it becomes the point of perversion to continue to feed from the breast. If they need to breast milk, give them a cup. 

Katena --- 14 years ago -

@shamwow I agree when you get teeth that is time to get off the booby. My little one is 2 and up until a few months ago he would come up and wanted booby. He has been weaned sensed he was a year old. I applaud all moms who breast feed but 4 is a little old. I did know a mom that did it until he was in 1st grade. Exactly give them a coup if they want milk. You are no less of a mom if you never have breast feed its a choice. 

Megan LeeAnne --- 14 years ago -

I seen something like this on youtube not too long ago...imo it's disturbing.I'm not too big on the breastfeeding period (only because I've never tried it) but I promised my husband that I would at least try it with this child and if I could get used to it I would do it for 6 months or when the teeth came in, whichever was first. My kids tend to get teeth real early lol. So, I know it's taking it off the subject but if anyone has tips, etc please pm me!!! This may be my 4th child but don't know jack about breastfeeding. 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

I have been seeing this picture in several places today and every time I am disturbed. That boy looks extremely well nourished and I doubt any of it is from the breast milk anymore. Perhaps when he was an infant and pre-toddler but it is obvious that in a lot of cases(as I am sure that of this mother!), the reason this goes on for that many years is for maternal fulfillment, because perhaps she refuses to let go of that stage. I hate that mentality of 'the kids will wean themselves naturally'. Well, then why do we potty train? I seriously don't think she allowed this kid to use his diapers until he 'weaned' from them. Pacifier? We wean from those too. Baby food? Yep that too, so why is breastfeeding different? I don't know if I made a point or not, I am confused with putting it in words, but I am just disgusted with these people. 

AwesomeSauce --- 14 years ago -

I don't agree with teeth being a deciding factor, my son got teeth starting at 4 months ;-) we were only able to breastfeed up to three months due to his inability to nurse and my lack of response to the pump. But with my next I will try again, I think a year is good. Beyond that, I start to get weirded out by it, personally.

I'm all for attachment parenting and extended breastfeeding... But that's way extreme. And it's not a freaking competition to see who is "mom enough" to do things like that. After a certain point I think it's detrimental to the child's independence and can negatively impact their social lives. 

details --- 14 years ago -

The only thing that bothers me about this is the caption. "Are You Mom Enough" Some women can't breastfeed at all. Some women choose not to. That doesn't mean they're any less of a Mother.

I also can't stand to hear "Breast is Best." Unless you add "in most cases" to the end of that, it's so completely false. Back when I was pregnant with my oldest daughter I remember the NYT did an article called "Breastfeed or Else" which was complete crap too.

If you can breastfeed, great. More power to you. Let me know when they send you your trophy. Just kidding! But seriously it's articles like this that fuel women who already think they should be up on a pedestal because they breastfeed. Not saying all BF Moms are like that, but I've met quite a few. 

Pepper --- 14 years ago -

When a child is old enough to chew their food it becomes the point of perversion to continue to feed from the breast. If they need to breast milk, give them a cup.

I'm sorry, that's asinine. It's recommended that babies be breastfed for at least that first year when it is possible for the mom to choose this. Some babies start teething at 4 months. My 4 cut teeth from 7-9 months. So I'm a pervert for feeding my infant who is learning to masticate their food at 7-9 months? Please! I personally think 3 years old is creepy, but way to go from one end of the spectrum to the other. I definitely have a problem with moms making other moms feel like less of a parent for choosing (or not choosing!) to formula feed. Obviously, the reasons are varied. Still, I have no problem with "breast is best." It is. May not always be ideal or even be possible, but it is nutritionally unduplicated. It's so complex...it literally changes with the baby's nutritional needs...not to mention all of the immune factors, etc. I have no problem giving credit where credit is due...so yes, breastmilk is amazing stuff, but I hate seeing articles like this because it fires up that knee-jerk how dare you reaction & that's counterintuitive to the end goal of recruiting moms to attempt breastfeeding when possible. 

details --- 14 years ago -

So if a Mom contracts HIV after her baby is born breast milk is still better then formula? Or if she starts drinking heavily or using drugs? Or if she has to take medication not recommended for lactating Moms to keep herself alive? That goes beyond what's just not ideal in my opinion and crosses into the "unsafe" territory. That's why I have a problem with "breast is best". It's not always, not in all cases.

I just wish it could be less about the blanket statements and more about just supporting each other for making decisions that are best for us as individuals. 

Pepper --- 14 years ago -

I have no problem with "breast is best." It is. May not always be ideal or even be possible, but it is nutritionally unduplicated.

Not at all. Reread. I was shooting for middle ground. It is best. Obviously not in every situation. There are always gonna be mitigating circumstances/cases and I was not referring to the exceptions. Nor was it a judgment of any kind. All moms need to be supported, all moms need to be informed. 

Pepper --- 14 years ago -

Oh, in case I wasn't clear, I personally think it's freaking unnatural to breastfeed a 4 year old!!! But c'mon, don't make it out like it's molestation to take the infant through the first year if they learn to chew food :/ 

staindingbymyman --- 14 years ago -

I read this earlier today on FB I think the follow up article is better[url=http://healthland.time.com/2012/05/10/extended-breast-feeding-is-it-more-common-than-we-think/]Breast Feeding Older Children[/url. I think its awsome that some women are able to BF for that long my mom extended BF my baby sis well into toddlerhood I would love to do that with this one but he dosnt care too much for BF. It would be cool if BF was more accepted in the states its the norm almost everywhere else and not uncommon for 3/4yrs to still nurse its good for them. Im a crunchy mom but I think Dr. Sears pushes the whole AP thing a lil far. This article did what I think what it was intended to do and get ppl talking about BF. 

staindingbymyman --- 14 years ago -

http://healthland.time.com/2012/05/10/extended-breast-feeding-is-it-more-common-than-we-think/ 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

Details, that is such an ignorant and stupid statement. I think it is a given that a mother should not breastfeed in those situations. Breastmilk is the best food for an infant from a healthy and responsible mother.
Some mothers simply choose not to breastfeed and that is okay too. 

details --- 14 years ago -

Obviously not in every situation.

If it's not best in every situation, then it's false to claim that it is best. That's my point. I understand though that it's much less catchy to say "breast is best in most cases" even though that's closer to the truth.

ll moms need to be informed

Totally agree that Moms need to be informed of the benefits of breastfeeding, but not told that it's what's best for everyone, period. Give them the facts and let them decide.

As far as breast milk being nutritionally unduplicated, maybe right now. But in another 10 years, who knows? There are new studies coming out all the time that show the benefits of breastfeeding are, in some cases, dramatically overstated. Medical opinions change all the time. Formula is closer to breast milk today then it ever has been. I sincerely hope one day they duplicate it all the way and this silly debate comes to an end.

I'm just gonna step away from this now. For ten years I feel like I have had the "breast is best" motto shoved down my throat everywhere I turn and it's a topic I feel very strongly about. I don't want to offend anyone so that's all I'll say. 

details --- 14 years ago -

Details, that is such an ignorant and stupid statement

No, what's ignorant is not being able to admit that there is a teeny tiny possibility in a small number of cases breast milk is not best.

Goodnight. 

staindingbymyman --- 14 years ago -


Totally agree that Moms need to be informed of the benefits of breastfeeding, but not told that it's what's best for everyone, period. Give them the facts and let them decide.



As you said in most cases breast is best and its not for everyone and everyone isnt able to BF. I feel strongly that breast milk is best for baby but BF should never be pushed on any mother somtimes formual is just what works. Iv been having problems BF my 7wk old from the start so I pump every two hrs but Im crazy like that most moms in my sisutation would have thrown in the towel but we are working on BF and I hope that he will eventually get it down and we can BF till hes ready to stop. But I dont think we are 10yrs away from fromual being as good as breast milk there are soo many things in it that cant be copyed like the anti bodies or the way it changes through the day to be what baby needs. I read the other day that its been found that breast milk at night chemcial makeup changes to help baby sleep I mean how cool is that, formual can never do that. 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

Details, what bothers me is that you probably know better, but you typed that anyway to discount breastfeeding mothers. It almost sounds like you have an agenda against breastfeeding, and I know females that do. I doubt they will be able to replicate the properties of breastmilk exactly, they will never put antibodies into forumla. How would you feel about drug companies dumping vaccines into your baby's main source of food. It is just as bad as giving kids random antibiotics for the heck of it. So yes, for most babies, mothers milk is best. (Especially children prone to allergies to cows milk and soy).
SBMM: pumping every two hours is miserable. I did that with my son until he was 7 months. 

staindingbymyman --- 14 years ago -

did that with my son until he was 7 months.
OMG go you! Iv been doing it sense he was 4days old and he will be 8ws on Monday. We are working on BF and I got him to nurse twice today which was a small victory for me :). Did you ever get your LO to BF or did you just pump? 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

I pumped the entire time. Congrats on getting your son to latch :)
I was having trouble with my daughter too, but the lactation consultants at Madigan are awesome. 

staindingbymyman --- 14 years ago -

Yeah I met the one in the peda clinic, she gave me my pump. I had trouble bf my first so I used a nipple shield but the ob put me on the pill and I dried up so he was only bf for 3mo, so this time I was ready and my LO refuses the shield so I pump(thats what im doing right now:)) Im determind to get him just on the
breast but he prefers the ease of the bottle. 

AwesomeSauce --- 14 years ago -

^^^^ pumping is miserable! That's why we only made it 3 months. I couldn't take it any longer! 

staindingbymyman --- 14 years ago -

Its defiantly miserable 

MASC --- 14 years ago -

i dont know if its the same one as someone else mentioned, but if you go on youtube and look up....

nah, ill just link it. thats how disturbing it is, im actually looking it up for you!

" target="_new">bf @ 8 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

Lol, she needs to find a new way to comfort herself. That's just ridiculous. 

ella ella --- 14 years ago -

"As a pediatrician, I believe that every mother should breastfeed her child for at least six months, preferably a year (even longer if they like)," KP.MD commented. "This, however, is extreme. And the photograph -- everything about its composition - sends a message that I find tasteless and more than a little disturbing."








Agree with this doc, its disturbing, at this age IMO we are teaching our children about privacy, and parts, to flaunt your tatas well your kid is attached at this age is insane to me, and completely not okay. Its weird, and not cute.

get a life mama, and get your kid into something else except your boobs.

lonely much ? 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

Im determind to get him just on the
breast but he prefers the ease of the bottle.


I am praying that you do!!! I was able to get my champion eating 2nd child to latch but I had issues w/ my 3rd. He was a preemie and in the NICU for 3 1/2 mos. I pumped religiously, I even quit taking my meds so that he could get breast milk because being a preemie I knew that he'd need gentler milk. Believe it or not, when you give birth 4 mos. early your milk adjusts! Anyhoo, I pumped for a total of 4 mos. then started to latch him on and finally was on breast only BUT all the pumping took a toll and my milk started to dry up. Pumping is never the same action as an infant's mouth so my boobs produced less and less. I was so desperate because my baby was hungry and I offered the breast all the time to encourage production and drank lots of fluids but to no avail. I had to make peace with giving up nursing because my baby who was just 6 1/2 lbs at 6 mos. wasn't growing much. Hopefully you are able to do it! Good luck! 

R --- 14 years ago -

I find it crazy how women beat each other up over this issue.

To each his own.

My personal feelings are that I was glad to be able to BF my youngest til she was 7 mos. That's when I called it quits for a few reasons, teeth and going back to work. I tried with my oldest but we just couldn't get it to work and I switched to formula after 5 days. I almost typed I quit or gave up after 5 days but then it sounds like I'm beating myself up. I made a legitimate choice with both kids.

I think to one year is an appropriate time frame but that again is my personal opinion. If you go longer, your choice, shorter time, your choice, straight to formula- your choice. Live and let live on this one. Unless Momma is starving her babies, why does it matter to you? 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

I breast fed. Loved it. Gave me great boobs. Breast fed till babies were 9 months. They were done nature had evolved.
Now what every other mother does is not interesting to me. Dont care what you do or dont do. Like you could care less what I did with mine. Ladies of America get a grip. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
women

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground