Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

How wrong is this???

who's talking here?

Sandra 2
Megan LeeAnne 1
Soon to be ex Bond Girl 13
Brenda E 1
details 1
myopinion 18
AwesomeSauce 3
Swiss Mrs 3
a4137440uu 9
NotUrFool 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

I was wondering when it ok to leave a marriage?

Mine has been terrible for years. We have one child together, but nothing in form love or bound keeping us together other then that.
I have put immense time and effort into trying to work things out, and though they are no longer bad in that all abuse has stopped since his return from his last deployment, however, all love and trust and physical attraction is still gone having been lost during those years of suffering.
The only things that really currently keeps me is not wanting to remove my child from a home with her father and not wanting to risk losing his family because they have been the only real solid form of family I have ever had. And even though they are aware of our past relationship issues, I don't think they would look past my leaving now because those issues have now stopped. 

Megan LeeAnne --- 13 years ago -

In my opinion if there is no love/physical attraction or anything keeping you together don't do it just for the child. The child will grow up and realize that there isn't and can cause far more issues than dealing with you separating. I was between the ages of 4-8 when my dad was married to my 1st step mom (didn't know my mother much) and I still remember their relationship...to this day it is the reason why I trust absolutely no one. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

Since having our child almost 3 years ago we have slept together maybe 6-7 times and have not yet since he has returned from this past deployment a few months back. 

Swiss Mrs --- 13 years ago -

You can always try to take steps like counseling to try to work things out. The only way it will work is if both of you want to try it. There are many resources on post for help. You just need to decide if you think you can learn to love him again. Best wishes to you! 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Past abuse?
Personally I would leave. I stayed in a marriage for 10 years that was emotionally, mentally and yes at times physically abusive. I did it because I felt it was right spirituality and financially I did not think I could support me and my boys. And I thought that emotionally it was best for my boys. And him. NO NO NO. My boys and I barely made it out with our sanity security and feelings in tact. We ALL see therapists doctors and are in intensive behavior mod therapy. Because he did not look like Al Bundy and sit on a couch with a beer and a hand in his pants.......and because he didn't hit me EVERY DAY OR WEEK. I convinced myself the "episodes" were ok. Its about control. Abusers want control. In whatever way they can. Even when you don't think they have it. Listen, do not ask how wrong this is. It is your choice only you have the facts. You MUST LISTEN TO YOUR GUTT. And another thing just saying .......this no sex no love thing. I wonder, whose really in control over that. Him? You? I would think really hard about that answer. Good luck. Love yourself. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

And
His family? Knew of the abuse? Did what?
Action speaks louder then words. What did they do about it?
Did they enable it? Turn their heads?
If they did. You may not really have a friend there, but a foe. Abusers learn it from somewhere. Its a learned behavior. I would go get a victims advocate on post. It is private, confidential and a good start. They are located by the police station on main. Pick their brains. Talk it over. There is no harm in speaking ones mind. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

Call me crazy but I don't think that you should leave just yet!I personally believe that if there is no abuse of any type most marriages can be saved. It does take a ton of work, on both your parts. If he is unwilling, then there's no point in staying. I think the first step is talking to him about how you feel and how you want your marriage to be(be realistic) and move from there. If he agrees and is willing to get counseling, then the rest should fall into place. You say that all love, trust and attraction is gone yet those are all things that can be regained, if you both want. I've been married for 20 yrs and I didn't always love, trust or feel attracted to my husband, as I know he didn't feel those things toward me at times as well. But the issues are addressed and worked on. All marriages go through this, you are not alone. I remember the early days when my husband said 'marriage shouldn't be like this, we should be happy', thankfully he's grown and realized that no one is happy 100% of the time, much less when it's 2 of you! Communication is the key. I wish you luck but it sounds as if you've given up all hope and until he says he's done, then perhaps you should feel a little hopeful. Marriage takes work forever, you don't ever reach a point where you say, hmmm, I love my marriage and lay back and enjoy, it's a lot of work! As for his family, living in hell is not worth having a family, you can find family and friends anywhere! Good luck and whatever choice you make, I wish the best for ya! 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

She clearly stated "all abuse has stopped "

Which clearly states their WAS ABUSE.

Point in I will not make a fool of MYSELF and tell you some ridiculous personal propaganda because its what "I know"

Gosh. Why would I YOU have all facts and pieces here.

But abuse? I'm sorry there is a certain formula for this. And you will need to educate yourself on it. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

Why are you so bitter toward everyone geez? She asked for advice and I gave her my opinion, just because it differs from you doesn't mean that it has anything to do with you or that you have to criticize or attempt to belittle me. You are one hate-filled woman MO. I will not reply to any further comments from you so you can write whatever you want, I happen to feel like a bigger person today! 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Huh?
Ok. Not entirely sure I understand at all.

But back to the original point?

Had nothing to do with our comments but hers.
I stand by my advice. Seek council do not ignore abuse. End of story.
Sandra I don't think we have ever met? So no offence taken. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

Yes all abuse has stopped! We spent the last two years prior to this last deployment in marriage counseling and with him in anger management on a weekly basis and have not had ANY issues of that nature since. I will not say that I not still worried about it reoccurring someday, which is probably why I am so hesitant about opening back up to him in any way, but we have done a lot of counseling. Now though, I just don't know if it would change anything further in terms of how I feel, IF i could get him to go again.
And not that this is alright now that I am here, but I WISH I HAD left before. But I had serious postpartum depression after having my child and completely in the wrong place mentally which is why I never left then. 

AwesomeSauce --- 13 years ago -

Only you can make that decision. You're a stronger woman than I for sticking through abuse, and trying for this long. I don't know how your relationship was before all that, maybe it was worth the effort. But only you can say when enough is enough. It is YOUR relationship, not ours, and not his family's. Good luck in whatever decision you make. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

^agreed.
This is tricky. I wish I could hug you. I remember a time when just a hug would have been worth more then a million bucks. Keep your head up. Love yourself. 

details --- 13 years ago -

The best relationship advice anyone ever gave me came from my Dad. He once told me that two people can work through anything and come out stronger, if they are both willing to try.

I know this true. I watched my parents marriage survive infidelity, extreme financial issues, severe illness, and more. They will be married 32 years next month and they are both happier and stronger then they've ever been. But both of them worked really hard to get there, and it's not peaches and cream all the time. I've also seen it with my husband and I...we have had our issues and worked through them. Both of us agree that it made us stronger and taught us a lot about each other, as a couple and individuals. But both of us had to work at it. Sandra is right...it's not easy and it takes a lot of work on both parts. If he's not willing to try then there's really no point. But only the two of you can decide that. Good luck. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

I disagree strongly. And I do not blame others for not " getting it"
Men who hit women and OR verbally emotionally abuse.....are just that abusers. Now so are child molesters. In fact if you speak to mental health professionals they will enlighten you similar tactics for control are implemented by both types of abusers. Now stay with me right about here ladies ... ...IF a sexual abuser will not admit he or she has a problem that would really make us sick. Right? I mean gross. Now a domestic abuser who uses very similar tactics just feels and look different ....why should anyone feel any less sick about it?
Now here is my actual point. If she is a victims of domestic abuse the question is not "is this wrong?" Meaning the possible reflection on divorce .....no the question is HE a abuser? And if he is how does she help her self.
And this innocent child. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

You stated above he broke you're trust before when he was really "engaging" in his abusive ways. Your wise. You should be on guard. He should be receiving on going treatment for his potential to relapse and abuse again. I would not stay if I were you.....if he wont get on going treatment. If capable once.....if capable twice.....well thirds are probably pretty likely 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

The reason I am asking is if it is wrong for me to leave NOW is because he has spent three years getting help to change his abusive behavior and has indeed changed almost completely from how he was during those times. So the problem is now me, because despite his efforts, I am still not able to get past what happened when he was like that.
Now, I just don't know if I ever could get past that but feel bad because of how hard he has tried. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

I understand. And that is a difficult situation. Are you receiving treatment? From being the victim of his abuse? I suggest it. It is incredibly liberating. And no hun its not your fault for being untrusting. If you put your hand in a dogs mouth and it bit you....well doing it again would come with a little reservation. Now the divorce issue .....seek great council on that girl. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

I was thinking about your question about leaving "now". And that being confusing for you because of all the changes he's made. And it's no longer a current abuse situation ....but more a "after math" one. That is a very profound question. One that cannot be answered easily. Because forgiveness does not mean forget ..... but if he has truly redeemed himself, then that is hard. I really suggest some therapeutic inquiries on your part. Get as much help as you can to make the big big decision. Maybe try a separation period? 

Soon to be ex Bond Girl --- 13 years ago -

I was wondering when it ok to leave a marriage?

NOW if your gut is telling you. I am so desperate for help I am spinning in circles trying to get it where my narcassist (seriously he is) husband has been emotionally abusing me for years... and I didn't even know! I mean he was very manipulative and sneaky... anyone that has been married to a psychopath, sociopath or narcassist can testify! Don't wait like I did until its an emergency and you are stranded. My Narc seriously took out all money to account and stuck it in another. I have no money whatsoever... this doesn't seem legal! 

Soon to be ex Bond Girl --- 13 years ago -

The reason I am asking is if it is wrong for me to leave NOW is because he has spent three years getting help to change his abusive behavior

So, what was the cause of his abusive behavior? PTSD, Narc? Why did he feel he was ENTITLED to hurt you? 

Soon to be ex Bond Girl --- 13 years ago -

You must think like a survivor in my mind. There is no time for victim thinking. My husband has been over the years breaking me down, isolating me, dehumanizing me... does your hubby ever do gaslighting?It is very dangerous... form of abuse although it doesn't come across as such. Many commit suicide as they fear they are going insane. This is when I started to notice how my husband was doing this. I truly thought I was losing my mind to the point, my hair was falling out. Now that I am filing and running to a safeplace... he is hiding the money and I can't get any help? Something is so wrong here! Hes an officer and maybe its the good ol boy tricK???


Gaslighting is a form of psychological abuse in which false information is presented with the intent of making a victim doubt his or her own memory, perception and sanity.[1] Instances may range simply from the denial by an abuser that previous abusive incidents ever occurred, up to the staging of bizarre events by the abuser with the intention of disorienting the victim. 

Soon to be ex Bond Girl --- 13 years ago -

victims advocate on post

hMMM.. Do I have to reside on post or can they deal with people who live off post? 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

His abuse stemmed from growing up in a house where his mother allowed his father to abuse her without any complaints from her, a steroid use problem and then PTSD made it worse after his first deployment.
The steroids are history and we are still getting him help about the PTSD to ensure it doesn't flare up anymore but his parents relationship is still a sore subject because they both treated it like it was a normal expected part of life and marriage so he use to also believe this. He claims to understand that it is not normal nor allowed or ok, but who knows how ingrained it is in him. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

and he use to do that gas lighting all the time! Only what he would do is whenever I would pick up to leave with my child during an incident, he would start rambling on and accusing me of abusing her, saying things like who would believe me over him with my history of mental illness and depression, if I left he would take her and make sure I never got to see her again. and being in the state I was which was usually disoriented from what had happened, I would believe him. Or I would place my child in her crib and he would claim I had THROWN her in the crib, or that i slammed her on the bed and arguing with him was pointless. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

And honestly, its more stuff like that then the actual physical abuse that has me so reluctant to trust him again. Him being able to say those things to me and make such horrible claims to me when he knew I was fragile already emotionally really showed his true nature and just how heartless and soulless and vindictive he is. 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

And how do you ever learn to trust or open to someone like that when you know it is in them? 

a4137440uu --- 13 years ago -

It was like a big funny game to him to see if he could push me to almost killing myself because of the horrible things he would say to me and taunt me and then once I hit the breaking point, telling me I'M the crazy one. Which I am not saying that I'm not, but holy crap man! 

Soon to be ex Bond Girl --- 13 years ago -

Girl, take a look at narcassistic personality disorder or psychopath. I know that society has given them like the ted bundy identity... but there are many out there among us. And you husband displays some characteristics and I am sorry if he is, as it is a grim reality. There is no cure.... Such as my husband, he lacks the ability to have remorse or feel true feelings for someone. everyone and everything is just a pawn on his game board to up his stand in power. Its scary when you read it, the stories of the women were all dead on... sorry, there were some men too. I am by no means, calling your husband one, I am not qualified to diagnose, but it will give you an idea. Unfortunately, most go without being diagnosed... because of course the narcassit thinks they could never be flawed! And if they do say it, its a mask, a scheme. They are sneaky and will literally make you insane! 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground