Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Your Baby Can Read

who's talking here?

Rebekah 4
goddessanne 3
Amy L 1
*Lauren* 1
**family of 5** 2
Sally 1
C&J's Mommy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Rebekah --- 16 years ago -

Anybody tried it??? 

Amy L --- 16 years ago -

No, but I heard its good, someone was selling one on LYS awhile back. 

Sally --- 16 years ago -

Too expensive. Buy a book. jk! A friend of mine did it with her daughter and she swears by it 

*Lauren* --- 16 years ago -

I've heard about it. We haven't tried it mainly because it was so expensive! If you do get it, let me know what you think! :) 

Rebekah --- 16 years ago -

ehh...I think I'm with Amy! LOL... 

goddessanne --- 16 years ago -

I did some research on it a while back. It is no good if you want your child to have reading skills (and spelling skills) later on in life. Yeah it's impressive and I'm sure it does work, BUT it teaches reading the wrong way. They teach a child by memorization or to recognize a word as whole. Schools, on the other hand, teach phonics. We initially learn to read by pronouncing letters. So while it's impressive they can "read" the word can before their first birthday, come elementary school they can't even read the word candy. Even though the words can and candy are closely related, the child will look at the word candy and say huh because he never knew how to say "cah" for c, "ah" for a, and "enn" for n. Lol...I don't think I got those pronounciations right but you get the picture. I think it's kinda like teaching a parrot to read. Parrots can "recognize" certain words, but they can't read a book. I think many still swear by it and I remember a post online about a teacher using it, but I personally won't. I'd rather try the old school Hooked on Phonics program. 

**family of 5** --- 16 years ago -

know of the program but have never used it. I did the same type of stuff with my children and all of the children in my care when I was in the child care field. Kids learn EVERYTHING so fast at younger ages. I dont like the idea of most of the "baby can read" programs, some seem great but others focus on sticking your child in front of a tv and that to me is stupid. You can do the same thing working with your child and using flash cards that are easy to make. For older children you can go to starfall.com for beginning reading and work with them as well. 

**family of 5** --- 16 years ago -

I dont think it is a horrible thing, alot of people learned to read by memorization.But you have to know how to work with it that is the problem. When I made my reading cards and worked with all my kids (mine and childcare kids)I did a route method but we sounded everyhing out each time instead of just useing the sight to sound method most of these programs use. 

Rebekah --- 16 years ago -

Yes...besides the price, that was my main concern...do they actually "read" words or do they "pronounce" and COMPREHEND what they're reading. I learned to read by memorizing words, and to this day I can't spell to save my life...I also learned my multiplication tables the wrong way...when most people memorized that 3x4=12, I memorized 3, 6, 9, 12, 15, 18, 21, 24 etc...so I have to count in my head four times...3, 6, 9, 12...by the time I've done this most people have already come up with the answer lol...it's even worse when it's bigger numbers like 48x38...I'd have to count by 8's 8 times, (using my fingers to make sure it was exactly 8 times), then four times, then count by 3's 8 times, then 4 times, then add it in my head...by that time I've gotten the numbers mixed up (because YAY for me I'm dyslexic too~!)...so I would already know to break out the pencil and paper (or calculator)... I just don't want to "help" my kids learn something early in life that is only going to be good for them while they're that young....great if he can read "Hop on Pop" now, but if he can't read "Of Mice and Men" when he's in high school, what's the point?...And then when it's so much "WORK" to read in high school, he'll end up like me and never read anything unless he HAS TO (I wont even read menus...I look for a yummy picture!)... And YES any program that teaches through TV and OTHER PEOPLE, would be much better taught by the PARENTS, in my opinion...as long as the parents know...if they don't, then they need to be sitting there learning WITH the kids ;) Either way it's better to be involved in helping your children learn and experience things, than to let them sit in front of the baby-sitter-box and hope they'll learn something from it... Sorry that was so long :D 

goddessanne --- 16 years ago -

familyof5: Indeed, a lot of us learn by memorization. Even college students use memorization, but the point I am making is a solid foundation of phonics will be best. When I was young I learned fairly quickly to use mnemonics. I still use mnemonics because it is so much easier to retain stuff like that, but sometimes it does catch up to me. I'm not disagreeing with you though because younger kids need a bit more than just teaching them how to pronounce something. They learn better with other stimulus of course. I was a Nursing student and we all used flash cards to memorize body parts, medical terminology, etc. I'm doing my Masters in Education and heck I just used them yesterday while studying theories :) Flash cards will never get old :) 

C&J's Mommy --- 16 years ago -

I agree with goddessanne. English wasn't my first language and when I first learned it, I recognized words buy how they looked and never sounded them out. I was able to read some English words in preschool only by memory, but once Kinder started and we learned how to sound things out, it made more sense to me as to how everything worked out in the English language, lol! And now, I can only read, speak and write English and some French.. Not even my own native language... LOL! 

goddessanne --- 16 years ago -

Rebekah, I totally understand what you mean. That is how my husband multiplies! He was trying to teach his younger brother to multiply that way and it just seems complicated to me. Anyway, you have the right idea so at least you can feel better NOT buying it...lol. Good luck! 

Rebekah --- 16 years ago -

hee hee...well I suppose it's actually helpful to multiply that way in SOME situations...like checking your division or counting money...I count money fast because I don't have to count how many nickles and dimes I have. I just count by tens till I get to the nickles, then count by fives etc. :D 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground