Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Does anyone know?

who's talking here?

Shelley 1
JustcallmeSuz 3
Nancy 7
miss2 1
brittney 1
whitwhit 1
HisGoddess 1
princessslips 1
age 1
candlegirl 1
mrsella :) 3
Krystle 3
sensesfailrockergirlyahoocom 1
Eliz 3
mandie 1
Momof2boys 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Nancy --- 16 years ago -

I really hate to put my families business on here, but I'm so sick to my stomach right now I can't see straight! My question is: Does anyone know, another soldier that would kicked out for not making weight? My husband was just flagged; I think he was 1% over on weight even though he did extremely well on the actual exercise part. This is the second time he was over weight since being at this command. Now they are talking about kicking him out. So I'm just wondering if anyone knows what happens, how long it takes, etc?? Yesterday was my birthday and he gives me this news. We are buying a house and I just went and picked out all the interior stuff and now I think we might have to back out and lose our earnest. I’ll def. have to quit school b/c I can’t afford the non-military rates :( I'm just sick to my stomach I'm so worried. He got home at about 11:30pm and I’ve been crying ever since. He has been in for 12 years and NEVER been in any kind of trouble. I just don't understand why this is happening.  

candlegirl --- 16 years ago -

I think it would depend on the command. I've known of soldiers being flagged for months and never passed a PT test. 

HisGoddess --- 16 years ago -

My husband has been threatened with being kicked out for being over weight for the past three years. I dunno about your husbands unit, but every unit my husband has been in uses that as a motivational tool. Unfortunately for my husband though, he'll NEVER be the weight they want him to be. It's not for lack of trying, it's just how his body is built. 

Krystle --- 16 years ago -

my husband can pass the pt just not make tape hes been flagged they threatened him with kicking him out too but it never happened 

Shelley --- 16 years ago -

I found a sort of study guide type thing about this subject, looked through it a bit, but you might check it out and it may give you some better insight... http://www.docstoc.com/docs/27655923/Army-Weight-Control-Program_-Army-Physical-Fitness-Program/ 

Eliz --- 16 years ago -

he'll NEVER be the weight they want him to be exactly. my husband has explained all this to me before, but i really can't remember. but they measure their neck as part of it, and if you have a skinny neck they think the rest of your body should match. it involves other stuff obviously. my husband has been flagged before, and as long as he showed progress they didn't care. every unit is different. he needs to talk to someone about what actions they expect from him. how long he has to achieve it. etc. 

Nancy --- 16 years ago -

Well I guess it's good that ppl have been threatened but never kicked out.... CS- Same thing with my husband, if he loses anymore weight he is going to look emaciated. He is so muscular, what do they want a twig?! Or I guess b/c he has a skinny neck?! I don't know it's crazy! I just can't take anymore stress. I'm already upset about my last class, and this new one I'm in is already kicking my butt. My kids have had so many apts and we are trying to fight to get my oldest an IEP. Then this really?! Oh I need some meds to help my mood bc I'm losing it! This is just sad he is a good soldier and this is how he gets treated. And we never cause any problems, yet we have to live in fear now?! 

Krystle --- 16 years ago -

yea my husband said the weight and tape measures they go buy are from the 1950's when everyone was really small and skinny 

Nancy --- 16 years ago -

Thanks Shelley. This PT test came after he was at Lost in the Woods for a few months. So he was eating in the Dfac (sp?!) and it was snowing there so they didn't have reg PT. I think he was 6 whole pounds over weight. I would love to only be 6 pounds over weight! 

Eliz --- 16 years ago -

nancy. if i were in your shoes, i would just take a step back and calm down. yes it is a big deal IF he gets kicked out. he just needs to talk to someone and have what they expect explained to him. and then go from there. 

Nancy --- 16 years ago -

Thanks Eliz, I defiantly have a type A personality and want everything planned out to a T. It drives me nuts when things change or I have to deal with the “unknown”. Hopefully everything blows over because if I don’t move out of where we are living now soon, it’s really going to get ugly. 

Nancy --- 16 years ago -

Thanks Eliz, I defiantly have a type A personality and want everything planned out to a T. It drives me nuts when things change or I have to deal with the “unknown”. Hopefully everything blows over because if I don’t move out of where we are living now soon, it’s really going to get ugly. 

Krystle --- 16 years ago -

if he is a good solider he can go to jag and they can help him fight it or at least help him 

age --- 16 years ago -

yeah i have seen tons of soldiers threatened but not put out. If he is only six pounds I wouldnt worry because that is really easy to get off for him to get within regs. Another thing he can do is neck exercises to increase the size. This works for alot of guys who are buff because most focus on the rest of their body and never think about those muscles. Most likely they will put him on remedial PT and redo the weigh in and tape in a month. 

Eliz --- 16 years ago -

Another thing he can do is neck exercises to increase the size. that's what my husband did. but he has had a few surgeries so they don't tape him right now. 

JustcallmeSuz --- 16 years ago -

as long as he can pass the PT test and has no other issues I highly doubt he will get kicked out. My husband is a body builder he is a big guy....never ever makes weight...not even when he joined he has always had to be taped....1% over is not bad....my husband has a soldier now that is 7% over...he wont be get kicked out...he is being put on the "fat boy" program to lose the weight. I think the standards need to be changed big time! I mean they want my husband at like 170lbs....he has not been that since maybe hs...he started lifting weights his sophmore year and has never stopped. Its crazy. 

JustcallmeSuz --- 16 years ago -

Another thing he can do is neck exercises to increase the size My husband has a 20 inch neck....LOL...tell him to do shoulder weights...helps bulk the neck at the same time! 

miss2 --- 16 years ago -

my friends husband was getting kicked out because he was over weight and he had the chance to pass his pt test and hes still in 

Nancy --- 16 years ago -

Thanks again ladies. I feel a lot better. I think it's just the way my husband came at me with it and I was already having a really bad day yesterday. I've been extremely emotional lately thanks to a lovely Bday present brought by mother nature.... Plus I'm just a high stress person. MissingHim, That seems to be what they want my husband to weigh he's right around 6ft. I just don't see how that is physically possible! Plus the poor guy is 31, not 21!!! 

mandie --- 16 years ago -

As long as your husband can get his weight down some, and pass 2 pt tests then he'll be ok. They are doing this Military wide bc they don't need as many troops as they did bc of the War, but since it's settling down some they are getting back on track with how strict they are about health and fitness. Have him do extra pt an even on the weekends and cut his meal portions in half. He'll do fine. Wish you the best of luck! 

JustcallmeSuz --- 16 years ago -

MissingHim, That seems to be what they want my husband to weigh he's right around 6ft. I just don't see how that is physically possible! Plus the poor guy is 31, not 21!!! Exactly my husband is just over 6' and 34...not as easy as it used to be! He is a stong mofo though! LOL 

Momof2boys --- 16 years ago -

Nancy, What platoon is your hubby in? I am the CO-FRG Leader of the unit & I am 1st platoon's POC.. I have heard of alot of people being flagged & threatened, but the new commander is not a small guy either.. He is short & has ALOT of muscle(sp?).. I have already had 1 meeting with him & just by talking to him he doesn't seem like the kind of guy to push through with a chapter & with him only being 1% over, thats just stupid.. 

sensesfailrockergirlyahoocom --- 16 years ago -

Hey nancy! my hubby was flagged for being a few percent overweight many times! they usually will give him a couple weeks and measure again. A few months ago they threatened to kick him out too and my hubby was in a bad mood that day too and told me and I was freakin out! my hubby is muscular too! so he'll never be what the army wants him to be. Don't stress too much about it! like someone said above me they will just make him do extra pt...like maybe twice a day! 

whitwhit --- 16 years ago -

Flags suck and being overweight can be a pain but I don't think they will kick him out. I know in some regiments if you can't pass after so long they can kick you out . Also if it's bad enough and presist without change or effort in other units I'm sure they can kick you out of the army for failure to adapt. It has to pretty extreme though and like I said if there is no change after so long and no effort thats a different situation than if they just didn't pass a few times. Just make sure he works hard, shows effort, and passes the next one and you will be fine sweetie. Just make sure they remove the flag though because they can forget to do it and it can affect later promotions! 

mrsella :) --- 16 years ago -

My husband runs a remedial program in our unit, and they are also starting chapter paperwork on the guys/gals that are not losing weight, even for the ones that are trying really hard, they added on a afternoon program even too help them out. Your husband and yourself seem like a family that cares and im sure your husband will put in the extra effort! May be home less but really get on top of it! They are getting really really strict, and it seems as if it is unfair, but they want healthy soldiers. Guys in are unit are purposly gaining weight also so they wont get promoted because they do not want the responsibilty it comes with . It sucks because it effects everyone that is trying. Get motivated and he will lose it fast you can make it a couple thing and itll make a more fun way then a miserable way. Take a deep breath and do all that you can !! 

mrsella :) --- 16 years ago -

My husband runs a remedial program in our unit, and they are also starting chapter paperwork on the guys/gals that are not losing weight, even for the ones that are trying really hard, they added on a afternoon program even too help them out. Your husband and yourself seem like a family that cares and im sure your husband will put in the extra effort! May be home less but really get on top of it! They are getting really really strict, and it seems as if it is unfair, but they want healthy soldiers. Guys in are unit are purposly gaining weight also so they wont get promoted because they do not want the responsibilty it comes with . It sucks because it effects everyone that is trying. Get motivated and he will lose it fast you can make it a couple thing and itll make a more fun way then a miserable way. Take a deep breath and do all that you can !! 

Nancy --- 16 years ago -

Tania, He is in 595, that's right, right?! Most ppl seem to be in 67. He needs to keep that info to himself from now on! I am way to high strung and will start having a panic attack from the second the words come out of his mouth! Plus it was just not a good day to be giving me such bad news!! Mrs.Ella, Thankfully since this whole fiasco I think he has already lost 5 or so pounds. He pretty much just needed to detox from the food he was eating while at training in MO. Since I cook healthier it's come off fast! Plus he is doing PT 2x a day even though I don't think he is formally on the "fat boy program" (I don't know the official term!). Thank you for all the support ladies! I can't even begin to describe the thoughts that were racing through my head. Then he came home today shocked that I was soooo upset over everything. I think he got the hint to NEVER say anything like this again till it's a definite! I don't know how I've managed to be a Military wife for 10 yrs with how much I like to micro-manage everything! 

mrsella :) --- 16 years ago -

lol! good he can do it ! i understand your fear though !!! ! 

brittney --- 16 years ago -

i had a friend whos hubby was kicked out for being overweight but he pushed for it lol. it was back in 2002 and he didnt wanna deploy. 

princessslips --- 16 years ago -

My hubby was chaptered out back in 2004 while on deployment for weight. It didn't matter with all of his awards and pt scores being excellent. He passed every one, but his neck measures big. Five years later, he re-enlisted, but having been chaptered out, there were lots of waivers and bs to go through. Hang in there. I think it all depends on the unit and the mood the one in charge is in that day! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground