Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Gastric Bypass vs LapBand

who's talking here?

Candi 1
Jeanette 1
sidney 1
Yep i finally popped Aug 13th 1
Katena 1
Mrs C 1
kadena 1
Sandra 1
REDLADY 2
Happy in Washington 1
SweetPea 2
buttersgirl 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Candi --- 15 years ago -

Anyone have any insight on either of these? Thank you 

buttersgirl --- 15 years ago -

Candi,
Im a RN, and i think they are both harsh. From what i understand lap band is for people who are over weight but dont have to lose over a 100 lbs.. and GB is for people who have to lose more than 100 lbs.
I think if someone needs to lose weight the best way is working out and eating better. I recently joined weight watchers and have been verry successful in losing weight. I have alot of weight too lose my self. and this isn't an easy task at hand... for sure.
I think if your serious about losing weight i would talk to your doctor. However; i know they require people to lose 20 to 30 lbs before they will consider you, and you have to meet many health requirements, and you have to do a mental evaluation..
hope it helps... 

SweetPea --- 15 years ago -

Candi from what i read/heard the lapband is a little safer than gastric..dont quote me on that one but thats what i have leared so far...Also, with the lapband, if you hate needles then it may not be for you because if the band ever needs adjusting, they stick a needle in your tummy and inject the silicone where it need to be, vise versa...Lapband is a belt tied around the stomach and Gastric they actually cut your stomach in half....Also, if you are not a certain weight percentage then they may deny you the surgery...You have to be so many lbs in order to even be looked at for that type of surgery...sometimes you can find a doctor who will do it for you just because the "patient" thinks they need it..but most doctors dont want to risk a lawsuit so they have to access your eating habits, weight, etc,. before they can approve you for the surgery...O, lapband is cheaper than gastric as well...Umm, lets see what else....O, have you tried other methods of losing weight because sometimes if you document all the weight programs you have tried, you also may be an excellent candidate for that surgery seeing that NOTHING else will help you lose weight..

Sources:
INTERNET..hehehe, i was thinking about getting it when i ballooned to 234lbs in 2008 but I did it the natural way...it took 2 years and now i have hit a plateau, the weight just want come off anymore...

If you are considering it, GOOD LUCK and I wish you the best...:-}} 

REDLADY --- 15 years ago -

i'm getting ready to have it done...lapbad has less risks and wont' lose as much. but has lots of upkeep.
gastric is more risky but will lose more at faster rate.
either way with both there are lots of things involved...it will be a LIFESTYLE CHANGE NOT A DIET. also you dont' have to lose any weight before you're considered. 

Yep i finally popped Aug 13th --- 15 years ago -

lol the only thing that works for me to lose weight is pregnancy lol...after my son was born a week afer he was born i was down to prepregnancy weight...(230_ yes put it down i dont care lol...anyhow i was determned to lose weight so i took all the crappy food out of my house and got lots of fruit and veggis,brown rice,no soda very little juice...a snack was a handful of carrot sticks no dressing lunch was a chicken(grilled) salad or a tuna sandwich with a few carrot sticks or a yogurt...dinner was usually some kind of chicken or fish and some yummy sauteed veggies....i cut out all the crap and was at the gym(YMCA)4 days a week for at least 2 hours minimum but usually 3 hours.i ran on the treadmill,lifted weights,swam,got on the elliptical...and even did zumba 2x a week...i didnt even lose 5 lbs and i did that for 8 mo....i finally gave up and went back to eating all the crap food that i love and the yummy burgers and stopped working out...i didnt gain anything not even 5lbs....its been 3 years....now that im prego i have lost 8lbs but im only 16 weeks lol.....with my last pregnancy i lost 25lbs 

SweetPea --- 15 years ago -

@RedLady--

GOOD LUCK on your surgery!! I hope all goes well...

Sending positive vibes your way!!! 

buttersgirl --- 15 years ago -

strange... my best friend is having it done in April and she had to lose 20 lbs to make sure she didn't have any other conditions. could be different doctors, different rules? in the you will see where they require weight loss!

http://www.aboutgastricbypasssurgery.info/gastric-bypass-surgery-criteria.html 

buttersgirl --- 15 years ago -

@ mommy2b2011... i am the same way!! i always lose a ton of weight when i am pregnant. 

Sandra --- 15 years ago -

I had gastric bypass almost 6 years ago. I had no complications and it was wonderful, BUT you have to work on your true reason that you eat. I lost 100 lbs., in the last couple of years, I've put on 20 of them. It is almost a given that you gain some of it back, most people do. But I feel like I'm forever on a diet and trying to lose weight and I feel ashamed that I had the chance to be thin and I feel I blew it. My husband always supports me and tells me I'm doing fine, so if I could give you one piece of advice, is to work on the reasons why you eat. Mine is because I am bored. I eat w/o thinking and at the end of the day I beat myself over it. I haven't stretched my pouch cause I still get full pretty quickly but I just eat too much in between meals. If I have my 3 meals a day I can lose up to 5 lbs in one week, no exaggeration, but I just can't stop myself. On that note, would I do it again? IN A HEARTBEAT! 

sidney --- 15 years ago -

I had Vertical Sleeve Gastrectomy in January and have lost 43 pounds so far. To me it wasn't as invasive as the Gastric Bypass and didn't have as much upkeep as the Lapband. Also with the lap band there are complications with wear and tear around the band that could eventually wear holes in the stomach. Also, I am not a big needle fan and I didn't want to have to be poked monthly for the first 12 months to get the right fill level. There are a few other options besides the Lapband and Gastric you just have to do some research and go through the seminar and classes that they provide. Also if you want more information this is a great website.
http://www.thinnertimesforum.com/ 

REDLADY --- 15 years ago -

http://health.yahoo.net/experts/dayinhealth/lap-band-surgery-weight-loss-it-safe
this is actually on the front page of yahoo a bit ago...i just read it and it is a great article 

Mrs C --- 15 years ago -

I had GB surgery 8 years ago. In order to be completely successful with any of the weightloss surgeries, you need to realize they are not a quick fix and require a lifestyle change. You need to change the way you think about food and exercise.

I went from 235 lbs and a size 22 to 122 lbs and size 4-6. 

Katena --- 15 years ago -

I had it the gastric bypass 3 years ago. I only had complications this year due to a leak. I was at 350 and am now at 190.I had a baby which was a surprise since hubby was fixed. I am now working to get my skin off other than that I would do it again in a heartbeat. 

Jeanette --- 15 years ago -

Well for me its medical reasons why I am considering both. I was never a big eater but my health has ALWAYS suffered. Just last week they said I have Hypertension. I have had several Heart issues the past couple of years. So I know for me its not just about "weight lost" I just want to be health for me and my family. We will see tomorrow what they say. Best of luck everyone 

kadena --- 15 years ago -

i had the gastric bypass almost 5 years ago and no complications, alot of people are for it and alot are against it, It i what u make of it. if you follow what they tell u then u will succeed but if not you will have problems. I was 322 when i got on the table to hve it done and now im 127 and that has been my weight for over a year. what ever u decide just research it, but now they make u go thru more than what i went thru to get it and pay attention to what they r telling u 

Happy in Washington --- 15 years ago -

I had gastric bypass surgery over 3 years ago. My initial weight was 300 lbs. My final weight was 150 lbs. A lot of people assume that this is the harshest surgery and not worth the risk. You should educate yourself on both surgeries and then make a decision that is best for you. I went in to the seminar demanding the lap band because I listened to what others had said about the gastric bypass. I was terrified. These people had very little knowledge about the surgery and were only telling me what they heard and not what was true.
As with any surgery, there are always risks. I have seen someone die following the gastric bypass and I have seen someone die following the lap band. I also know someone who died after getting a simple procedure such as an extraction. (I am a Respiratory Therapist so I have seen a lot.) I had very little complications from my bypass. Yet, last year I coded twice when I went in to have my gallbladder removed. Totally unexpected because no one warned me about that.
I feel that I am a true success story. I have no lose skin. I could always lose 30 lbs in 30 days easy. I just couldn't keep it off. Losing and gaining weight constantly will take it's toll on you. I tried Jenny Craig, Weight Watchers, Slim Fast, etc. There is a reason why these businesses are successful, its because of unsuccessful people.
You need to attend a seminar, ask lots of questions, you have to be 100lbs overweight or if you don't fit that criteria, you have to have other qualifying health issues, and you will need to take a psychological inventory to see if you qualify. I assume you have Tricare. I got approved in less than 2 weeks and I know people who got approved in 6 months. It all depends. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground