Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Private or Public School?

who's talking here?

goddessanne 2
Julie 1
Kathryn 1
Kristin 2
Megz 2
FoleysWifey 6
Carolina 3
ellaella 2
Pepper Potts 1
HappyGoLucky 2
sothrewwithlewis 1
someonesangel 1
andbabymakes6 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

My daughter starts kindergarten this year. She is in Michigan with her dad right now, but she's moving with us after we move to NC. Only bc school starts Sept 6th and we have to be in NC Sept 10th, so it will be easier for her to start school there.

My ex found a private school but its $10,000 for half day kindergarten, and $14,000 for full time kindergarten.

Now the are he lives in is bad for the public schools, a lot of schools in Detroit were closed down so all those kids are moved into the city schools, they have classrooms with 35-40 kids in each class.

I just really am not sure which is better for her as far as social skills, and learning. 

ellaella --- 15 years ago -

I say if you can afford a private school try it out. And see how it goes, to me personally they will get a better quality education, supplies and resources.

Advancement and it does look better for college and such.

Better curriculum also.

So its really on whats important to you and for your child, and if you can afford it. And make it a permanet thing and not tossing your child back and fourth in education.


We pay a hefty price for pre school and to me its worth it, privately owned and very amazing curriculm. 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

Yeah just for kindergarten its gonna be $14,000 because I want her going full time, she should have started school last year but missed the cut off date which I think is stupid. But each year it gets more and more expensive. I just don't want people making fun of her bc we are working hard to afford the private school, we aren't the type to be able to write a $14,000 check all at once. 

ellaella --- 15 years ago -

I would be amazed if they made fun of her. Why would someone make fun of her for you wanting a good education for her. thats all that matters but there is stupid people in this world off course.


Pricey very pricey but at the end its your choice. 

Julie --- 15 years ago -

If she is moving in with you all shortly after school begins I would start her in Public school. The reasons I would choose this route is because Fort Bragg has excellent schools from my POV. They are Department of Defense schools and My kids each received a solid education at these schools. I am not sure I would be inclined to pay that much for school when I was already planning on transfering schools. 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

She's gonna do kindergarten there bc once we move to bragg we will be buying a house and doing painting, and decorating and have a bunch of other stuff to do. Then we will see how her first year goes and go from there. 

Kathryn --- 15 years ago -

If kids go to private school they don't have to deal with the RETARDED state testing! 

Kristin --- 15 years ago -

Our son goes to private school here and we make monthly payments...we couldn't afford to write a check for the entire amount either! Don't feel bad:) 

Carolina --- 15 years ago -

I have went to private school all my life as did my siblings. The curriculum was definitely better than the public ones that were in my hometown. They schools can get pretty pricey but I learned alot and had many opportunities that I wish of would have taken full advantage of. Good luck in ur decision. 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

I just thought she might get teased for being a "poor kid" compared to what all the other parents make & drive. I know private school will be better for learning, but I don't want her to be depressed bc we aren't rich.

I just think since we can afford it, then it shouldnt make a difference how much money we make, but kids are cruel now a days. 

Pepper Potts --- 15 years ago -

My brother went to private school as the poor kid. He is fun and athletic & made his own way. He definitely felt it though when it came to the school activities & clothes. I don't think this will be an issue for a kindergartener & people should appreciate you looking for good education. Plus, if the situation in Detroit area schools is that ugly then I bet alot of parents, not just the wealthy ones, are making that move too & your daughter should mesh just fine. 

Carolina --- 15 years ago -

My family wasn't rolling in it by any means. I went to school with many rich kids but I didn't care and they didnt seem to mind either. Of course I was teased from time to time jyst like they were but we all understood that our parents worked hard to get us what we wanted. In high school esp I went to an all girls school were the majority were white and affuluent. Some of these girls would drop thousands on shopping trips on the weekends. It honestly helped me evaluate wuts really important and wut I want for my kids now. 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

Thanks for all the info ladies :-) makes me feel a lot better!

Now I'm having an issue, my husband is against the whole idea..it isn't his money that is paying for it. My daughters dad gets a discounted rate I guess bc his income. He did just get a job after graduating in January and he will be making about $6,000 a month. My husband now doesn't like the thought of her going to private school, he hates my ex and its frustrating to be in the middle. My ex and I didn't have a bad divorce in anyway and we still get along fine...I just don't understand why my husband has a problem with her getting a great education! 

Carolina --- 15 years ago -

Try to talk to him that is going to benefit ur daughter or maybe u can test it out for a year and see if private school is for her. 

someonesangel --- 15 years ago -

Foleywife.. let him cool down. i hate my husbands ex and they have a great relationship--i think its almost better if they hate each other! sounds weird, but maybe its not that he doesn't "want" her to get a better education but possibly he is butt hurt that he isn't making that kind of money? id let it go for a few days (or even weeks!), and approach the subject again when he is in a better mood and has had time to take the emotion out of the topic. just my thoughts. 

sothrewwithlewis --- 15 years ago -

FoleysWifey, just take your time and investigate. Cumberland County school system is WAY behind!!! I mean WAY behind. I chose to drive my kids 30 miles to school and drove from their school 45 miles to work and all back to pick them up when I lived there. They went to Harnett County schools. They have a very strong success rate for kids. Also as someone stated above about the DOD schools on Fort Bragg, they are great compared to the other schools. BUt of course if you will be buying a home and wont be going there, you wld have to have her elsewhere. We will be back that way next spring. I cannot wait! I am so disatisfied with the schools here. They are way behind. Woodbrook has been behind for 5 straight years. I pulled my kids out and they did SO much better. Just get the info for yourself online and make visits. In the end only you and your family can decide what is appropriate and best for your child. I wish you and your family the very best of luck! :) And PS I am STILL TOTALLY jealous you get to go there! Maybe one day I will see ya on Braggbookoo! lol 

Megz --- 15 years ago -

Foleyswife I went to both public and private school although mostly private. From my perspective the quality of education was better at the private schools, the class size was smaller and the overall atmosphere was better.

as for the price, a lot of them have scholarship programs that you can apply for or financial aid. for example if it is a catholic school and you are catholic, the diocese will have funding to help. usually this help goes to registered parishoners first but if you talk to the schools ahead of time and let them know what is going on they might be able to help you.

also NC schools start earlier, like mid August. so keep that in mind 

goddessanne --- 15 years ago -

From a future teacher and school counselor's perspective (my Cert. is in K-6 and I am one course away from my Masters in School Counseling), kindergarten is pretty much the same wherever you go. Honestly, they still do a lot of "playing" in kindergarten. I mean come on, realistically, it is the first official grade level. How much would you teach a child that young? Think about their attention span. So, if the deciding factor is based solely on the thought that your child will get a better education, I would advice don't do it. I don't think it is worth the money. At this level your child is not interested in making straight "A's" or making an "A" in a test. I personally would not send my child in a private school early on. If I do consider it, it would be during high school where a private school may better prepare your child for college. I say may because some public schools do a great job as well. I went to private schools during my primary years and public schools in middle and high. (Some of classmates graduated from Stanford, Brown, Princeton, etc.) Anyway, think about our personal experience. What we need in college now or apply in life is what we learned in middle/high school. Anything taught in kindergarten I learned beforehand from my mom, TV, or its basically common knowledge. 

Megz --- 15 years ago -

From a future teacher and school counselor's perspective (my Cert. is in K-6 and I am one course away from my Masters in School Counseling), kindergarten is pretty much the same wherever you go. Honestly, they still do a lot of "playing" in kindergarten.

actually in nc on post kindergarteners learn the abcs, basic numbers, start simple addition and have to know their address, phone numbers and parents names, how to tie thier shoes and about 300 sight words. we just moved from fort bragg and I tutored my gfs son who was in kindergarten. they also start reading towards the end of the year.

their special classes (each day is something differnt) are PE, Music, Art and Spanish. yes Spanish. 

HappyGoLucky --- 15 years ago -

I went to both private and public and in my opinion private school is more advance. Yes u play quite a bit but by the time I got out of Kinder I was just turning 5, was speaking 2 language, and knew how to read. Then my mom made the horrible mistake of taking me out to put me in public school. All I remember is being bored because what they were teaching me, I had already learned two years before. By no means is this a teachers fault because I think they are amazing but I do wish the schooling system offered them more funds n smaller class ratios. Smaller ratio classrooms are easier to teach more material simply because the teacher has less students to handle while in a regular setting of 30+ kid, the poor teachers have to split themselves ten gabillion ( 

Kristin --- 15 years ago -

My son will finish 4K at his school this year and he is reading right now. I remember learning my letters in kindergarden and doing the phonics with headphones on...he's getting a much better education than I did:) They have 14 students in his class with 2 teachers so I think that makes a huge difference. 

goddessanne --- 15 years ago -

I did want to add many factors can exist. Is your child gifted? I just noticed that you are considering a private school for safety reasons. That is, of course, a great reason to push for a private school. I suggest tour the school. Private schools usually accommodate parents who want to see them in action. Judge for yourself if there is a major difference. I also suggest observe for a while and on different days. You can't get a true evaluation for only a few minutes. Not all private schools are advanced or better...believe me. Truth of the matter is, they are a business. They will advertise what the parents think will sell. So unless you see it for yourself... test scores, public rates, rankings, etc. don't just automatically go for it because it is a private school. Just like a public school, private schools vary in quality. Don't assume private and expensive automatically means high quality. I hope everything works out for you. At the end, mother's knows best :) 

andbabymakes6 --- 15 years ago -

Kids lean valuable lessons in Kidergarten. Both academic and social. Thats where they learn to "do" school. My 1st grader was a daydreamer in Kindergarten and got caught up in the hub bub of the other kids, but now that she's in 1st, she's applying the skills she learned of waiting patiently, working quickly but carefully, and not socializing until it's time for that. I'm proud of her. You've got a lot of things besides academics to consider- her safety, and the school manners/ study habits she'll learn just to name a few... Good luck! 

HappyGoLucky --- 15 years ago -

Dang it. I chopped my quote by mistake. Booooo. But, the ladies have stated what was on my other half which is do what works best for u n your family. Safety is number one no matter what in my opinion and hey, if she can get a fantastic, above average education at the same time, then go for it. I cant vouch for Detroit but Ive heard awesome things about private schools nationwide as well as a few public schools. Good luck Foleyswifey. U seem like an awesome mommy. 

FoleysWifey --- 15 years ago -

Well I don't have time to fly to MI and tour the school so I have to go off what my ex has to say. He's taking a tour and meeting the teacher this week. I feel kindergarten is a pretty important year so I really want the best. I think its worth the money bc they don't have 35 kids per class room...I don't see how any kids could learn without having time with the teacher, and a classroom that big, the teachers don't have time to sit with each kid individually.

My daughter is very smart and has a pretty good attention span, she catches on to stuff very quickly.

I'm about 90% sure private school is the way to go, until she moves to NC with us at least. Since she's starting school in MI I really don't want her going to public school, the good public schools are an hour to 2 away and I know my ex doesn't have that much time to drive her back and forth everyday. I would start her in school here, but shortly after school starts we are leaving, I don't want her to miss any school if possible :-)

Thanks everyone for your input, it really opened my eyes! I am so excited for my daughter to go to school :-) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground