Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Car insurance

who's talking here?

brittney 1
ShamWow 1
AlohaLohi 1
FL GIRL 5
Megz 1
a1125604uu 1
NadaSuperstar 1
fam0f3 1
HeatherLynn 4
Shelley S 2
AFwifestuckinWA 3
a3690138uu 1
details 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

FL GIRL --- 15 years ago -

We have USAA and I feel like we are paying to much...but every time we've had a problem they have been excellent. My question is who do you have? How has their customer service been? 

AFwifestuckinWA --- 15 years ago -

We have had Amica for the past year and I love them. No one, including USAA, is able to beat their price for us. My favorite part of them is that they quote and bill on a 10 month plan but coverage is for 1 year. So for 2 months you don't pay for insurance! We have experienced wonderful customer service with them. In January of this year my husband was rear ended by a motorcylist on 512. Our car was totaled out (pretty scary a bike could total a midsized sedan!). We had to wait a few days before we were able to verify if he had insurance and which kind because the guy was in the hospital and you don't have to insure bikes in WA state. Thankfully he did have Progressive insurance. Amica was able to get a quote on how much our car was totaled out for. Most insurance companies would wait for Progressive to handle that part and then Progressive would cut us our check but Amica didn't. Amica cut us our check for the totaled car and then they fight with Progressive to get that moeny back. Amica made sure we had our money as quickly as possible, we had a rental car until we got our money and then they were very good about calling my husband and checking up on him and getting our medical settlement taken care of. Turns out the guy didn't have enough coverage to cover the damage to our car plus the damage to the SUV he landed in after hitting my husband and we would have got less money if Progressive was the one handling it. Amica said they take the hit if Progressive can't pay them back the full amount that Amica paid us. We basically made money on this accident, which is the only good thing that came out of a bad accident.


3 weeks later my husband was rear ended on base (thankfully very minor compared to his previous accident) and Amica took care of us right away. Got our rental right away, our SUV was fixed quickly and that case was settled just weeks after it happening.

I can't talk highly enough about them but I also know that rates are different for everyone so what might work for my family may not work for you. 

AlohaLohi --- 15 years ago -

We just switched from USAA to State Farm. Our agent is Nathan Trodahl. He is awesome. We are 21, 23 years old with a dodge caliber '11 and a dodge dakota '01. We were paying $311 for full on the caliber and liability on the dakota. When we switched to state farm Nathan helped us so much. He saved us $70 in insurance a month PLUS we got renters insurance with our policy and GAP coverage :)
if you want to call him his # is 253.693.2111 

details --- 15 years ago -

We have always had USAA auto and renters insurance up until this summer. Their rates have always been comparable to anyone we've compared them to and their customer service has always been fantastic. Right now we have MetLife only because a year of free insurance came with the vehicle we purchased in July. 

Shelley S --- 15 years ago -

Dang a year of free insurance, I would LOVE that! We have had USAA for a few years and we have been hit twice and both times they were so quick about getting us into a shop and a rental. Free insurance would be about the only way I would leave them at this point. 

FL GIRL --- 15 years ago -

I agree Shelley they have been great...just looking for something cheaper. Geico is the cheapest I've found so far. But I'm scared to switch. 

Shelley S --- 15 years ago -

I had Geico for 17 years and they dropped us without notice. I mean I understand WHY they were dropping us, but an email or something snail mail would have been nice. Our son was still on our insurance and got a DUI, so yeah, I get it, but after 17 dang years you would THINK they could have bothered to give us some kind of notice. Only reason I noticed before we were actually dropped so we could find insurance was because they usually billed a bit before the renewal time and we hadn't got anything. I emailed asking what was up and they told us. 

fam0f3 --- 15 years ago -

We have USAA and they are pricey for us but are the lowest I've been able to find. Gah it kills me! But they have great customer service and through everything from hit and runs to theft they have given us our money the next day! 

a1125604uu --- 15 years ago -

USAA denied us one year due to my husband being "high risk" even though we're both military. We had geico but switched to Nationwide when we moved here. They have been great. WE have 3 policies. We're both mid-twenty have full coverage on a dodge 1500 and liability on a saturn vue for under 200 a month. When Lakewood lost power for 2 days we filed a claim for the loss of food and had a check in a week. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

I've had geico since I was 16 and I'm now 21. My husband and I pay $141 a month for full cov on my car 2005 hyaundai sonata and liability on my husbands truck chevy extreme 2003. I don't think you can beat that! Lol plus we both have a few tickets!

I've been wanting to check out amica and see what they're prices are... Hmmm How much do you pay for amica? 

AFwifestuckinWA --- 15 years ago -

How much do you pay for amica?

We pay $172 for a 2008 SUV full coverage and 2006 Elantra full coverage. I had Allstate before and had the bare minimun requirements for WA state. Now we have very good coverage and pay less. We pay that amount only for 10 months and we don't pay the last 2 months but still have coverage. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Ok maybe I'll get a quote on their site! That's pretty sweet 

FL GIRL --- 15 years ago -

Wow I just got a quote from Safeco. For triple the coverage we have with USAA it's less than half of what we pay right now per month!! 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Safelight? I've never heard of that insurance company hmmmm maybe I'll check that one out too lol 

FL GIRL --- 15 years ago -

Sorry it was Safeco. 

HeatherLynn --- 15 years ago -

Oh ok lol I'll check them out too did u look online or call for a quote? 

FL GIRL --- 15 years ago -

I called Shay & Associates Insurance in Olympia and spoke with Brad. His phone number is 360-943-9974. He takes your info and finds the cheapest policy for you. 

a3690138uu --- 15 years ago -

Oh okay cool.

I think we're just going to stick with Geico, we only pay $141/mo. Amica wanted about $300 a month with less coverage ...um no! lol 

AFwifestuckinWA --- 15 years ago -

I think we're just going to stick with Geico, we only pay $141/mo. Amica wanted about $300 a month with less coverage ...um no! lol

Oh bummer :( I guess it's good there are so many companies to choose from. What works for one family doesn't necessarily work for another.

Forgot to mention that my insurance dropped when I moved to Puyallup from base. My insurance company at the time told me it was because base rates are based off of Lakewood and they have a higher auto theft and break in rate then where I live. I think my insurance dropped $20 a month or so when I moved. 

ShamWow --- 15 years ago -

I used State Farm before we moved back to WA and our rates got crazy high here so we switched to USAA. Then last year when my son got his license USAA had really bad rates so we went to Geico and our insurance dropped by 33%. Then just last month we switched back to USAA because they finally got their rates for teen drivers comparable to other insurance companies in WA. We have 3 cars on our policy and even with a male teen driver we only pay 300 a month and that full coverage with the additional personal injury for our teen and roadside assistance with deductibles of 500/500. We have 2 new cars and a 2005. so USAA really can be a good choice. You just need to shop around and compare. Also make sure you aren't getting coverage you aren't required to have or that duplicates the coverage already on your policy that insurance companies try to call by other names to confuse consumers.

With Geico you have to make sure of what your coverage are and in the event you have an accident what they include in your policy like roadside assistance and rental coverage. One of our friends had his car totaled right after they got here and he fought with Geico for 2 months before they finally got their payout and were able to get another car. 

brittney --- 15 years ago -

i have geico and have been with them for 7 years and love them. i have full coverage and pay 38 a month for our suburban. i got a ticket earlier this year and my rates didnt go up wohoo. 

Megz --- 15 years ago -

We just switched to Geico from USAA only because the rates here were too high for USAA. if we go back east we will go back to usaa 

NadaSuperstar --- 15 years ago -

We have usaa and our policy went down for the 6 month period with no changes to anything...you really just have to call and get a few quotes to compare! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground