Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

is this wrong?

who's talking here?

ShamWow 2
Eliz 1
Katena 1
rei3 1
Kathryn 1
Maui Girl 2
NadaSuperstar 1
ZombieMOMMYrawr 2
a2815654uu 1
Shelley S 2
Mommyof1 1
myopinion 7

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

A professor from NYU wrote a study on the negative emotional consequence in bringing children under the age of 10. Especially under the age of 5 into nursing homes. Not assistance with living facilitys. He says with the buffet of adult issues....like health and mental problems...bad smells...its a scary place where a child is being used for adult purpose not for the child him/her self. Now I did not include a few details. And the report is long and this man does have his PHD. I'm just torn.....is there no other way to look at this? 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

May depend on the child...I personally was visiting a nursing home very early in life because my grandmother and great grandmother (not mother and daughter) were both in them. I was probably about 5 when I started going and was 11 my last visit. I have to say, while some of it was a little sad, I actually enjoyed going. I not only visited with my grands, but also I got to go on rounds with one of the nurses who would take me "visiting" some of the other rooms where the people were still in fairly good shape, for lack of a better term. She told my mom that those people didn't get visitors and they enjoyed the company.

I would like to think in the long run, I'm a fairly well adjusted person and can't see where it had any negative affect on me. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Interesting. My mother who is also a child therapist had me visiting nursing home patients as public service when I was 8. I was not scared just sad. The Doctor was mostly going over a case study of a 3 year old he got into a lot of details. It sounded so dark and weird.....I'm so confused 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

3 might be kind of young for them to understand why the people live there. And too it may depend on who/what the child sees. I can see where someone talking to themselves or rocking back and forth may be a little scary to a very young child if they didn't understand why the person does these things. 

ZombieMOMMYrawr --- 14 years ago -

Seems this doctor would say the same about bringing children around other people with sever mental and physical handicaps. I completly disagree! I used to work in an integrated daycare where we took care of children with a variety of special needs and children without such needs. I never saw a negative effect on the children. In fact these children that are exposed to people w/ disabilities tend to be more empathetic and accepting then those kids who are different. Same goes for adults. 

ZombieMOMMYrawr --- 14 years ago -

Sorry I'm extremely tired. Grammar will be off today! 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

MD. Marc Siegal associate professor of medicine at NYU..."bringing a two year old into institutes such as these is sadistic, barbaric and assultive to a young child's sensibilitys.".... but he caps the age at 5 sorry not 10.....what do you think in that? It sounds dark.... 

Katena --- 14 years ago -

My boys at the time were 1,2,5,8,13. My 5 year was the only one that did not like it his grandmother had lost her leg the previous and he was upset. other than that I disagree. We were welcome by all these were my grandmother last few years and she got to met her great grandchildren. I believe it depends on the child but my children had no problem. This was the highlight of my grand mother day and the others that rarely received a visit from their family. I think a lot of people forget our older generation and I love hearing the stories from them. 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

I worked in a preschool that made monthly field trips to elderly homes. You can't put a price on the smiles the kids brought to their faces, and vice versa. They sang songs for them, played toss the balloon with a senior citizen of their choice, and some of them just sat on a S.C.'s lap and talked for a few minutes. It was a beautiful thing. I believe the school was trying to incorporate empathy with the children for this dmeographic because Lord knows that in this day and age, it is certainly lacking.

Furthermore, my little brother spent a LOT of time with our elderly great aunt and great uncle when he was very young (toddler through preschool age) because both of my parents worked at the time, and my younger sister and I were in school. They babysat him and took him to the nursing homes to visit their friends extremely often. While I generally perceive my brother as a complete douche most of the time, if there's one thing he understands, it's senior citizens. He can connect with them more than anyone else I know. And I admire that. 

Eliz --- 14 years ago -

my grandfather visited his mother every sunday until she passed away in 08. i am old enough to remember visitng her house before she went completely blind and then visiting her when she went into the nursing home. looking back, i realize how utterly sad it made me to my mawmaw getting weaker and weaker. this went on for 10-12 years. it's not that nursing homes bother me, but they definitely bring up some DEEP emotions for me. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

How could such a man, smart educated. Make such a opinion ....but not opinion as. Much a study...be wrong. Couldent we all be wrong. He showed a tape of a young girl ...a home video shot by her grandma who did not live in home. Visiting the great grandpa who was very old and had dementia. Long story short....the tape was shown to a group of kids the young girls age...the doctor asked children "whats going on" all the kids replied unanimously......she's scared. 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

Dementia is a scary thing. You never know how a person with dementia is going to act because THEY are afraid. I'm CERTAIN that in the instances I mentioned previously, patients that were a risk to others were probably kept in their rooms when the preschoolers came to visit. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Ya...I see it your way..,but its crazy....the child was caylee Anthony ...the grandmother ..Cindy Anthony. You may have heard of the names in the news 

rei3 --- 14 years ago -

when i was little my mom would volunteer at convalesent homes and take me along.It was the best experence i grew so attached to alot of the people, i loved hearing there stories.i never felt endangered or scared. 

Kathryn --- 14 years ago -

My daughter is 4 and had been visiting my 91 year old grandmother who at first was lucid and could interact with her a little bit. On December 11th, the day my husband left for Korea, she took a major turn for the worse and was placed in hospice care. We were able to drive up and see her one last time before she passed on the 3rd of this month and my daughter did not go in, family members took turns playing with her in the lobby. Parents should hopefully realize what a child can handle. 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

I think too many people today try to make something out of nothing and also try to shelter children too much to the point it is ridiculous. I would never have a problem taking a young child into a nursing home to visit someone. I worked in nursing homes for 3 years after high school in the dementia units, longterm care units and medicare hospital recovery units and saw many kids visiting and it's good for the child to see their family member and interact as it is also vital for the elderly patient to not get isolated from their family. Sounds like this person is a clueless moron. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

The "clueless Moran" has a PHD and is head of the medical department at NYU so he's pretty smart. I went to Sac-state......and we had heard his name there. I visited nursing homes as well as a child.....I just wanted to broaden my mind to soak up different opinion then my own. Thanks ladies. 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

PHD or not, this professor needs to do more research before putting out a paper on something that can do more harm than good. There are alot of book smart people out there that lack common sense and social skills. Just my 2 cents. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Ya....it was a ten year Study and most departments agree with the doctor. I would personally have to pick his mind in person before making an educated common sense, using social skills ...opinion on it. That's my 2 cents. 

a2815654uu --- 14 years ago -

I think it depends on the kid. My oldest even at one an two years old loved going. But now my youngest would find it scary. 

NadaSuperstar --- 14 years ago -

My son loves to visit people. He understands that sometimes people get sick and need more health. He is not scared, he likes to help visit. I think basing any case study off the Anthony family is a little faulty. Hopefully he had other data and case studies to pull from. 

Mommyof1 --- 14 years ago -

a nursing home to most kids is liking going to a hospital..
not to scary. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground