Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Let him walk

who's talking here?

goddessanne 6
JustcallmeSuz 2
ShamWow 1
R 1
Sandra 4
giffs fam 1
Shelley S 2
myopinion 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

giffs fam --- 14 years ago -

http://sports.yahoo.com/blogs/highschool-prep-rally/ohio-baseball-player-t-walk-graduation-caring-forcancer-102922017.html

If you want to sign petition

http://www.change.org/petitions/allow-austin-fisher-to-walk-and-graduate-with-his-2012-class-after-caring-for-his-sick-mom?utm_medium=facebook 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

This is so sad, some people really don't think. If I were one of the other graduates, I'd refuse to walk to honor him. It makes me wanna cry =( Most kids wouldn't do what he has done for him mom and to punish him like this over 2 absences over the limit. It's stupid. 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

No offense to anybody, but because I know most will side the boy I will provide a different perspective on this story. I am a school counselor and we have a similar case right now. A little different, but to cut the story short we have a student who basically attended less than 3 weeks of school (of the entire year!) because she was helping take care of her mother who has cancer. Really cutting to the chase here, but bottom line is law is law. Parents must have their child under the age of 16 in school. (I've always thought that responsible parents would at least consider homeschooling if the child must absolutely stay home.) We let one slip then it would be unfair to the others. In a counselor's point of view, it is NOT the job of the child to take care of something this big. We always say to our students let the adults worry about the adult stuff... focus on school. In our case, we were kinda upset at the mother for putting such a big responsibility on the child. My student now has developed seperation anxiety and other conditions from what she had seen and experienced with her mother. I mean come on... let the child just be a child. I think it is sad this child was given such a huge responsibility meant for an adult. Going back on this boy, even if his actions were the best for his family then the mother should have withdrawn him and considered homeschool. Really... withdrawing from school is not that time consuming or difficult. If the parent was responsible she could have done something. Outside resources are ample in America.. social workers, free medical, so much that she could have practically appointed some else to do it on her behalf.

I don't know the family, the actions of the school, or other pertinent information. What I do know is the media loves to print out sob stories. I could very well be wrong, but really I doubt the school simply wanted to be "mean". 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

We really need to hear the school's side and what they have done. In our case, we took turns delivering homework to the student's home (unpaid and beyond work hours of course). We referred and initiated so many outside resources, but family was always a no show. We even took turns picking the family up (personal gas and time) if the issue was transportation. We kept informing them about the law and consequences. So what's the school to do if they have done everything? Other families may take advantage of public services if we let one slip. Again, until we know exactly what the school did we can't just assume the boy was mistreated. Yes, the mother has cancer, but what about other students who are experiencing the same thing. Can we just grant all students excessive absences because they are taking care of a parent and allow them to graduate. Really, it's just not fair... Again, let the child be a child. Adult responsibilities should never be placed on a child at an early age. Some will be okay, but it may be detrimental for others
. 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

In a counselor's point of view, it is NOT the job of the child to take care of something this big.

Yes, the mother has cancer, but what about other students who are experiencing the same thing.

I totally agree with you. A child that age should not be caring for a parent with cancer. The emotional trauma that child has experienced is something no child should ever have to endure. Where were the adults in this situation? You don't pull your child out of school to care for you, you let them stay in school and learn and grow. And you don't traumatize your child like that. That is an adult responsibility not meant for any child. I also agree that he should not walk, he needs to go back to classes and get all the required days and education he missed. If anyone is to blame it's his mom. We all have struggles, but we don't neglect our parental responsibilities. Her cancer was no excuse to not make sure he had a proper education with all the resources there are for getting schooling today. I should know because I was very ill for a few years and never would have considered having my son home to care for me. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

I agree that what these children went through was a lot. No other way to put this. Life is not fair it's messy and it hurts. Not everyone is going to live thrive and take the same path. If I had no one else but my son and I was dying painfully of cancer. I hope my son would have the strength and heart to care for me. However I would make sure he was signed up for a homeschooling program. But when your dying of cancer pain is the only thing on your mind 

R --- 14 years ago -

Is it an option for him to walk but not get his diploma until he completes some summer school? I don't have time to read the article but I have seen that done before. They get to walk with their class with the understanding that the diploma is on hold until the needed course is complete. 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

I still don't agree. Goddes, you said your student attended 3 weeks, this boy was absent 16 days, 2 days over the maximum. There's a big difference.

In a counselor's point of view, it is NOT the job of the child to take care of something this big. We always say to our students let the adults worry about the adult stuff... focus on school.

One of my closest friend has a stomach condition that has her in pain and bedridden often. She has a husband that is deployed and was on the verge of being kicked out of the army for missing so much work to take her to the hospital. He was literally ONE incident from being out. She often is in the hospital, sometimes for days at a time and often has appointments and procedures done. As a military wife, most of us have no family wherever we are stationed. This is the case with her. She has a 17 yr old that she depends on for help. I met her because I do respite care for her, but aside from me she has literally no one nearby that can take on the responsibility for helping her. Ideally kids would focus on their school but what if there is no choice? I for one know that if I had no husband and was diagnosed with cancer, my family is in TX, I would have NO ONE but my kids to help me. Literally. 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

Is it an option for him to walk but not get his diploma until he completes some summer school? I don't have time to read the article but I have seen that done before. They get to walk with their class with the understanding that the diploma is on hold until the needed course is complete.

I read the article, it's just because of his absences, his work is done. I also checked out the FB page, he is not being allowed prom either. 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

When I was in high school one of my best friends was able to walk, but inside her book was a blank paper. She had to attend summer school to get her real diploma. I guess things have really changed a lot over the years. 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

WOW, Shelley I've never heard of that crap! See, that's where it's sad =( 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

Yeah we had a few in our class that had to. She had quit school for about a month our senior year, then came back and excelled and made up her work missed. But, technically she was short a few credits during her down time so she did summer school and they had a small private diploma ceremony after summer school was over. Well not private, but not a big a deal as regular graduation. 

JustcallmeSuz --- 14 years ago -

I am a mother of three who does have cancer and let me tell you NOTHING is more important than my children's education. There were days when my kids wanted to miss school to go to chemo and stay home and take care of my when my husband was unable to go with me. NOPE, school comes first. Yes, there were days I so wanted to let them stay home and care for me. I stayed focused on my kids and their futures. I also did not want to expose them to me that sick. They saw more then I wish they did when they were not in school.
Bottom line no matter the outcome of my condition, my kids have a future and a successful future requires them to graduate from HS. I refuse to be the cause of them not graduating. Period. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Great perspective
Not everyone is like that. 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

When I was in high school one of my best friends was able to walk, but inside her book was a blank paper.

Funny thing is a similar thing happened to me! I was top 20 out of 1,000 students and I was so surprised when I opened my diploma jacket and instead had a note that said please see the business office. I was like there is no way I didn't graduate.. I practically finished high school in 3 years! Turns out they withheld my diploma because according to their records I didn't turn in one textbook. I was so embarrased. Of course, it was a mix up, but didn't make a big deal out of it. I kept the note and it is behind my diploma just for memories. 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

this boy was absent 16 days, 2 days over the maximum

It differs in different states, but with us our max is 12. With our state, we have a 3, 6, 9, 12 rule... Your child misses 3 unexcused absences, we call... with 6 we call, request for parent mtgs., start interventions, counseling, monitor, etc. During a parent mtg. we make them a sign a form explaining the law and that they understand it, etc. We do our very best to not even reach 9. So if/when the student does reach max then really the parent was irresponsible. This kind of thing just doesn't happen overnight. Since it is a law that the mother broke (not the boy), I'm sure she got warnings, letters, "heads-up" way before he even reached midway his max. Again, I don't know everything, but I'm thinking the mother became neglectful. 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

Another thing I want to share was when we visited the home of my student, as hard as it was to start, the more important thing we brought up was the welfare of the child afterwards. Yes, the mother has cancer, but what about the boy? His life goes on. We were as sensitive as we can be, but we had to bring up the idea of what happens to the child if the cancer takes her life away. Luckily, the mother understood us with our intent.

I was thinking about both cases... the fact that there is no other adult around really concerns me. What will happen to the child if cancer takes their lives away?

If it were me, as hard as it is. Call me a martyr and all, but for the sake of my child, he or she will go to school. I will endure all suffering to give my child the best life he can have. I will encourage my child to finish his education so that when I'm gone I at least know my son has finished some form of education that will help him somehow when he is on his own.

I show true emotions to my own son now, but I do my best to be brave in front of him.

Oh wait...Missing Him...that is the point you were making :) 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

See I hate to speculate on this. I had brain surgery and was not so much myself for a bit. I wonder what would happen if I was dying in agony. I like to reflect though. It makes life more interesting. 

goddessanne --- 14 years ago -

I am a mother of three who does have cancer and let me tell you NOTHING is more important than my children's education.

You remind me of my mother :)

My siblings and I were in high school when my mom sat us all down to tell us she had cancer (survivor :). My younger brother cried, my older in disbelief, and I was so scared and heart-broken. She asked us to take life seriously and finish school.

I couldn't get her condition off my mind, but I did my best to excell even more in school. I figure I want to be one less thing my mom had to worry about. I dedicate all my accomplishments to her. One day, I'm sure your children will too :) 

JustcallmeSuz --- 14 years ago -

That made me tear up! Thank you! 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground