Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Whining 3yr olds!

who's talking here?

JustcallmeSuz 1
ShamWow 1
FL GIRL 1
Sandra 1
Megan LeeAnne 2
NadaSuperstar 1
Shelley S 1
peanutbutterjellytime 1
myopinion 4
camoworld 5

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

camoworld --- 14 years ago -

Oh my goodness, I need some tips/advice on how you ladies handle your whining 3yr old. I have tons of ideas but I am open to many more! My son is killing me and the whining has to STOP! HELP! 

NadaSuperstar --- 14 years ago -

They still do it age 4 too :-( 

Megan LeeAnne --- 14 years ago -

Honestly, I got fed up with it and told my 3 aand 4 yr old if they wanted to whine they can sit on their bed and shut the door. The longer they whine the longer they sit their. You have to be consistant with what you choose though. Within 1 week of me doing that the whining got significantly less. 

JustcallmeSuz --- 14 years ago -

Ignoring it. All they want is attention or a reaction. Just totally ignore the behavior. 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

That's what I did too, ignored them. Eventually they got bored and stopped.

And even teens whine, trust me lmao 

camoworld --- 14 years ago -

hahah I always ignore him. Ill continue to do so though. It takes everything to not want to smack him like a irritating fly buzzing around your head. Good thing hes still cute even when hes obnoxious. So far Ive been taking away his superheros everytime he whines....it works pretty well, but im noticing he is slowly begining to not care that they get taken away. 

Megan LeeAnne --- 14 years ago -

That's why I do the sitting on their bed now. They started not caring about their toys being taken away. 

FL GIRL --- 14 years ago -

I always say mommy can't understand you when you talk like that. You need to talk in your big girl voice.

My 5 year old has been in a mood the last few days. I'm not sure what it is but goodness sakes I feel like I'm getting flashes of her teen age years! 

Sandra --- 14 years ago -

I always said 'Im sorry, I don't understand when you speak like a baby' and stuck to it. If he kept whining out of frustration at my refusal to 'understand' his whining, then I said 'when you get your big boy voice back come see me' and I'd leave. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

I had no tolerance for this. Whining. My boys have some serious flaws. That one would not have worked for them. I saw allowing it as a weakness in me and I'm not ok with that. They would have choosen having NOTHING if they wanted to whine
I would out do them. Whine at me for an hour or six. Do it from your room. I will not be talked AT this way. I deserve better. They deserve better. Do not allow this. That simple. 

camoworld --- 14 years ago -

Do it from your room. I will not be talked AT this way. I deserve better. They deserve better. Do not allow this. That simple.

Well said. The room he goes then! Too bad we dont have sound proof walls. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

Its not easy.
I found myself thinking .....oh their just hungry, tired, needing me. Then when the crying from the room would die down, I would be on my way to resolve and confront. And when I asked if he was ready to be respectful he looked at me and started on round two. Oh its on. I shut the door and walked on realizing this kid thought he could out do me? I -- think--not. 

camoworld --- 14 years ago -

Ill keep you posted how this war goes tonight when he spends a good portion of his night in his room. 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

You should keep us posted. If you do this and its done with success. Meaning you would not tolerate naughty winny disrespectful little boys. You get a props and a kudos here!!!! Support and a place to vent!!!!!
Go Girl!!!!! 

peanutbutterjellytime --- 14 years ago -

I know this may not be a popular opinion but I am going to put it out there anyways. My youngest is a TERRIBLE whiner. In my Psyc class there was a whole section dedicated to childern whining. No joke! Well it talked about how we condition some kids into this behavior. I know that sounds stupid but hear me out. When I started thinking about it it made total sense. I was a single mom for the first year and a half of his life. I was going to school while trying to work and have time with my two boys. In doing that I had things to do while at home such as homework, cleaning house etc. While I would be trying to concentrate on homework my son would come to me to get my attention and I would tell him to hold on. He would persist and I would tell him to hold on for one min again (just to be able to finish typing or reading whatever) So then he would whine or cry and then he would have my attention. By doing that I reinforced his behavior. As adults we do this on a regular basis and don't even realize we do it.

Since I was able to pinpoint what I was doing wrong on my end as a parent I have made a HUGE effort to change my behavoir toward him. When he comes to me whining I explain to him why I will not listen to him and how he needs to change his way to approach me. When he talks to me like a normal human being I basically stand at attention to listen to him right away. It has been taken a lot a patience and change on my end but he is finally starting to come around and change his behavior as well as my own. I know most everyone else says to ignore him however in my experience that just reenforces that he needs to be loud and "annoying" to get attention. For a child, negative attention is better than no attention at all.

I'm just throwing this out there. Take it or leave it. Every parent needs to to what works best for them ;) 

myopinion --- 14 years ago -

PB&J
yes a vital point indeed. Correction on our behalf is the first action needed. Without that what follows is hear say. Assuming this whining issue is typical and not one stemmed from deeper roots. I suggest a mommy Makeover thus following demand on the child to follow.
If the attention is positive yet his human self keeps demanding more totally correct it with ignoring the bad behavior rewarding the positive. 

camoworld --- 14 years ago -

totally valid points/approaches. The ignoring him is just pi$$ing him off more. So on to plan two mommy changes/kole changes. Thanks ladies! 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

I wish mine was still 3. Just don't pay attention to him when he whines. And when he's not whining let him know that he can get your attention with out acting out for it. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
children
help
parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground