Has anyone read this article? What are your opinions on it? I personally don't see what the issue is. How and why is it "Disrespectful" to nurse in uniform?
I see it more as, "I can nurse my baby and STILL kick your A$@!" Not as a horrific thing to happen to military. I personally nursed my daughter in uniform 4-6 times a day while I was stationed at the pentagon and worked in an office of ONLY men and they never once had an issue with it. On occasion when I had a deadline to meet, they would ASK ME to just nurse her in the office opposed to going to the nursing room. And again, no one had even the slightest issue that I was in uniform and nursing my child.
I am not against nursing in public, but the blonde one is looking rather inappropriate for a woman in uniform. The picture could have been taken in better taste is all. I feel they are the equivalent of the gal on the cover of time magazine. It's all in how the picture was taken.
Agree with Sandra I get the point of it, and it can be presented as classy picture and make its point BUT the blonde is really not doing it right.. Her boobs are all hanging out.. and like BAM here I AM ?!
Personally I get they are moms and in the military but to expose yourself to this length is a little well ALOT not tasteful.
n public, but the blonde one is looking rather inappropriate for a woman in uniform
I completely agree with you about the blonde, she could be a bit more tasteful about it.
However, I am more asking, not about these two specific people or the picture, I am referring to breastfeeding in uniform in general because the article is written about breastfeeding in uniform in general.
The article is not done very well for most soldiers who do breast feed or pump are not doing it on a park bench but in a private area or covered up. I have in 17 years of Army life not once heard of an issue that an active duty soldier had with being able to breastfeed or pump as long as they could complete their mission or in other words do their job. At my work several of the staff pump but they must have someone cover their patients while they are doing it. I could only imagine how uncomfortable it is with the clothing because it is definitely not nursing friendly and neither are scrub tops
Exactly what she said, we are ALWAYS told mission comes first....that goes for ALL soldiers. Period. Family comes second. If a MALE soldier has to miss a birth etc. a female soldier should have to make the same sacrifices if it's required. Meaning if she has to PUMP because of needing to go to the field than she should do it, and not say, get excused from Field time, PT, etc, etc ONLY because she is nursing or get ANY special treatment.....the service does not allow you the same rights as the civ world, some you have to give up. That said, I have no problem with a soldier(like the one on the right) nursing her baby in uniform, as long as it's not interfering with the mission or her work, good for them. And I am so glad to here that the Army is so nursing friendly? who knew??... the girl with the twins? I am with every one else, it's not discreet, and for being IN uniform, I would say no....
I personally don't see a problem with it. I'm not comfortable nursing in public. I would bring Nathaniel to my room if we had company, and it's MY house. But I don't really see a problem with nursing two at a time, there's really not a discreet way to do that. A cover I suppose, but that would defeat the purpose of the picture, wouldn't it? I don't think it's sexual or distasteful at all. I would not do it personally, but don't think it's a problem. I don't at all think it's like the magazine cover photo- this is clearly showing the bond between her children and her while she feeds them, not a disconnected, defiant pose.
the military is not something that caters to women, or women's needs. nursing is another example of this. women should not get special treatment because they are nursing. i'm REALLY over female soldiers expecting/wanting/demanding treatment that caters to them. if you can sign the dotted line like a man, than you should be willing to sign over some of the extras that come with it like men do. BTW: blonde in that picture: totally tacky. Not an example of a loving, nuturing experience between mother and baby...picture made to be sensational and spark debate
I am for breastfeeding but it could have been a little tasteful. I have breastfeed 5 babies and done it discreetly. I am glad Army is pro breast feeding. But woman in general regardless of their job can kick ass. We are woman and can do it all.
The two in the picture are not even Active duty if I recall, I thought they were part of a reserve component. They should have featured the ones who live the life 24/7, if I got this part wrong I apologize, I did not want to do my research again.
Since I have no experience nursing more than one at a time- could someone give me an example of a better way to nurse, that isn't tacky? Without having any other knowledge, that is probably exactly how I'd do it. And I gotta tell you, it wouldn't be to show off some boob.
The two in the picture are not even Active duty if I recall, I thought they were part of a reserve component. They should have featured the ones who live the life 24/7, if I got this part wrong I apologize, I did not want to do my research again.
i'm REALLY over female soldiers expecting/wanting/demanding treatment that caters to them. if you can sign the dotted line like a man, than you should be willing to sign over some of the extras that come with it like men do.
I'm not sure what "special" treatment you are referring to. I signed away A LOT of extras to join the military instead of joining the civilian workforce and and sick and tired of MEN making comments like YOURS!!!! I work my a#$ off, push myself, get no sleep, go weeks without proper showers or meals, train just as hard, shoot just as straight, run just as fast, give up time with my family just as often and watch my friends die on the battlefield while almost dying myself just the same as ANY of the male soldiers but yet I am still treated with that same attitude and disrespect as you just displayed and all because I am female and honestly all I really have to say to that is GET OVER YOURSELF it's not only woman who request special treatment as you say!!!!!
Okay I doubt she meant all so calm down, and honestly being apart of this life for 6+ years I have met very little amount of female soldiers who dont step up and take advantage of having tits and a vagina to get there way.
I'm also wondering what "special" treatment female soldiers are requesting in regards to this topic? I don't recall asking for any. Are you referring to the breaks they request ever 3-5 hours to either pump or nurse? Because excuse me if I am wrong but I believe that MALE soldiers that smoke take FAR more breaks throughout the day for that. I also believe that MALE soldiers as well as female soldiers are typically given an hour and half lunch break daily and some even another hour for PT. I don't see anyone complaining about those? For the duration of time in which I was nursing, I did not ONCE take a lunch break. I instead used my allotted "lunch" time broken up in 15 minute fragments to nurse my child. I also remember not requesting a single thing more then I was given as far as time off after given birth, starting PT again at the same time despite the agonizing pain I was in from a complicated birth, I worked the same 12 hour shift everyone else did despite not getting any sleep at night and never did I complain about ANY of it.
i'm REALLY over female soldiers expecting/wanting/demanding treatment that caters to them. if you can sign the dotted line like a man, than you should be willing to sign over some of the extras that come with it like men do.
Sorry, I know this is off the original topic but I agree with this.
run just as fast, give up time with my family just as often
Females the same age as my husband have a whole four minutes longer to finish their run on a PT test. I'm just saying.
For the first three years my husband was here he had to work nearly every holiday, weekend, and always worked over night shifts, which meant he slept all day and had very little time to spend with us. This was because a female soldier in his unit claimed she couldn't find night/weekend/holiday childcare. So they made an exception for her and let her have all the day shift hours, forcing everyone else to pick up her slack.
There is a female soldier my husband used to work with who pumps at work. Everyone has to clear out of the office when she needs to pump for 20-30 minutes. This happens several times a day. What is so dang special about her that work has to stop to accommodate her choice?
What I'm trying to say is that while there may never have been any special exceptions made for you Belle, it does happen.
As for the original topic of this post, whatever. It's a boob. As long as they're not letting it all hang out after the baby is finished feeding then what's the big deal? Judging from some of the comments on the article though, I think it's some kind of violation of the uniform code.
I have met very little amount of female soldiers who dont step up and take advantage of having tits and a vagina to get there way.
Maybe I am from a different area of the army because I have met very few that have.
I don't mean to get upset, I'm really not, more just stating my opinion from my personal experience but a very GENERAL (as in ALL) statement was made about female soldiers. I worked FAR to hard and gave up FAR to much to let anyone say such a thing without a rebuttal.
I'm not sure what "special" treatment you are referring to. I signed away A LOT of extras to join the military instead of joining the civilian workforce and and sick and tired of MEN making comments like YOURS!!!! I work my a#$ off, push myself, get no sleep, go weeks without proper showers or meals, train just as hard, shoot just as straight, run just as fast, give up time with my family just as often and watch my friends die on the battlefield while almost dying myself just the same as ANY of the male soldiers but yet I am still treated with that same attitude and disrespect as you just displayed and all because I am female and honestly all I really have to say to that is GET OVER YOURSELF it's not only woman who request special treatment as you say!!!!!
I was going to ream into that person, but I think you said everything I was going to say and I love you for that.
As for the article, I think it's awesome. Could have it been done a little more tastefully...sure. And I think it would have meant more if it featured active duty service members, but all in all I think it does bring to light some very important issues when you're talking about breast-feeding in the military. One of the reasons I decided to chapter out when I got pregnant was that my unit was going to make me breast-feed and pump in the bathroom. It was a unisex bathroom and the only one in our building. I knew that they were not going to be supportive of my desire to breast-feed and although I would have loved to stay in AND be a mom, that reason (among other issues I had with them) pushed me towards chaptering out. I think that if ALL parts of the military were more accepting to breast-feeding and family supportive in general, more female service members would choose to stay in over chaptering out.
IDK...what the regs are w/regards to using a cover up in uniform are...infact I think that's the thing, there is NO regs regarding this issue...however, I can't help but wonder WHY are you at a Park in Uniform if you are NOT ON DUTY??? just to pose for a picture/make a social statement?
if you are off work, simply change your clothes, right? my husband changes before he goes anywhere. It's not as if you are asking THAT much. Not only that, because these women are not on duty etc. They got dressed up for this picture to be some sort of spokesperson, etc. That is not what the uniform is for. IT is NOT for your gain in making POLITICAL or SOCIAL arguments, which is what is happening in this picture. If you have to feed twins, simply Pump till you are able to be out of uniform, MANY women do this not just Army, my BF is a Bank manager she doesn't sit out in the lobby with her twins feeding the twins, she pumps and then nurses at home. These twins are ten months old so pumping is a viable and sensible option. Additionally, get REGS changed! don't just go and try and get publicity, try and affect change within the military if you are REALLY concerned, meaning write letters, attend all the forums etc. to get having a cover up while nursing in uniform addressed---- Tell me, can this Soldier Salute? Preform other duties with her shirt up and no hands free?
I don't even really see this as a breastfeeding issue. It's a professional issue, a soldier issue. Duty comes first. First, first, first...and that is the way it has to be.
I love that the Army has nursing rooms, because honestly I never thought they would be so supportive. But I feel like this picture actually sets female soldiers back a bit not vice versa
picture made to be sensational and spark debate And yes, it was made to spark debate, because that's what sparks CHANGE!! If it wasn't a sensational picture not as many people would be talking about it, and that means less people would hear about it, and less people will push for a change. It's meant to spark CHANGE.
For the first three years my husband was here he had to work nearly every holiday, weekend, and always worked over night shifts, which meant he slept all day and had very little time to spend with us. This was because a female soldier in his unit claimed she couldn't find night/weekend/holiday childcare. So they made an exception for her and let her have all the day shift hours, forcing everyone else to pick up her slack.
There is a female soldier my husband used to work with who pumps at work. Everyone has to clear out of the office when she needs to pump for 20-30 minutes. This happens several times a day. What is so dang special about her that work has to stop to accommodate her choice?
That is CRAZY, I will give you that. Those two things would NEVER have happened in the units I have been in, but the woman would never have requested them. However, the part about the childcare, male or female would have been given the same leeway about it. One friend of mine is a single mother and do you think that her unit cares that she is stationed in Germany away from everyone she knows? NO they don't, she goes into the field and does CQ just the same as everyone and has to come up with childcare for all of it and she DOES. She doesn't complain(to them). She finds someone to watch her kid for nights and weeks on end and when she deploys she signs custody over to her parents because she can not very well take her son with her.
Just saying, this is what I see and have always seen.
and as far as nursing at work? A baby at work is a distraction PERIOD, whether you are nursing or not, if you are on duty WITH your kid there, it's hard to say you can devote 100% of your attention to the task at hand ANYWAYS!...I get we all tow our little ones to work occasionally but, for mission essential duty. I don't believe babies at work are conducive it's a choice to work and have children.
My child was brought to me when I needed to nurse, I would run home or I would pump because I literally lived half a mile from work so it took all of 5 minutes total from door to door for them to get there or me to get home.
My child was brought to me when I needed to nurse, I would run home or I would pump because I literally lived half a mile from work so it took all of 5 minutes total from door to door for them to get there or me to get home.
Yes, Belle adore, and I understand you were on break, I get that...I see that as being a nice way to allow mothers to nurse...vs...the whole park picture, I just see it as why is this lady even in a park in uniform? volunteering to pose for a picture, to make a social statement and not even be ON duty?...it's almost like wearing your uniform to a soccer game that's on a Sunday, you have off. Just to get attention. Ya know what I mean?
I would say your situation is a GOOD example of Nursing while active duty..I would say this is a BAD example..that is why I said, I think it sets Female soldiers back
And just because woman are allowed 4 extra minutes doesn't mean we all use them. We are not allowed 4 extra minutes though because we are woman, it it scientific fact that our bodies are different and the way our pelvis and hips are shaped makes running a lot more difficult at high speeds. That is it plain and simple. We are also genetically leaker in upper body strength, hence the lower push-up count. On areas that we are the same, sit-ups we are required to do the same amount as men.
gah and we're shorter!! lol... it takes me two strides to everyone of my husbands ONE stride! lol, and we have boobs! I tell my husband to put on my sports bra and stick six to eight water bottles in it and then see how those push ups feel with 6 plus pounds of extra weight right at your chest--it's different! lol
I don't see what the big deal is. I get that she's in uniform, but if her babies have to eat then they have to eat. Pumping sucks and some people just can't do it. If you're at the park with your kids and your babies have to eat, you just whip em out, maybe they're both hungry at the same time and she couldn't wait 10-15 min. On the note about changing before you go out. I don't get why more soldiers don't do it. I'm always at the store or park and I see soldiers with their families, after work, in uniform. I'm pretty sure they went home, why not just change? lol I'm glad she's feeding her kids instead of starving them, or killing them and eating them, just saying... Most soldiers wouldn't do this anyway (bf at the park in uniform), and I think no one should be able to judge a female soldier until they have been in their shoes. I know this post is kind of all over this place, lol.