Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

What would you do?

who's talking here?

Misty P. 1
ShamWow 1
Maui Girl 1
LJsMomma 2
BelleAdoresMommaFriend 1
HeatherLynn 3
Brenda E 1
Leesah 1
Shelley S 1
33Whisky 2
Pandaroni 2
AwesomeSauce 1
Open Paws Pet Sitter 2
jden 1
Irishgirl 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

LJsMomma --- 14 years ago -

Ok so my family is going hom for 2 weeks for leave. Our old neighbor wanted to watch our dog for us. My dog is a mini weiner she weights about 15 pounds. I told her that if you take her for a ride in the car she will try to jump onto your lap when your driving so you have to keep your arm down or tell her no. Well the lady watching my dog who is about 60 decided to take my dog for a ride to the store with her. As she started to go out of her driveway my dog tried to jump into her lap and she jerked the steering wheel and sideswiped a fence post. It knocked her side mirror off and scratched he drivers side door up. She has a old ford little car im guessing mid 90's if that..she called me and told me what happened so my husband and i went over to her house and my husband screwed her mirror back on its still loose but now she can drive her car. without her mirror dangling. We told her if it doesnt hold we will call around and figure out how much they are my husband who shes doesnt know that well is kinda cocky and said well you will probably have to pay 60 bucks for a new mirror. I had said we could probably buy it for her and my husband could install it. She acted fine with it and still wanted to watch our dog (we leave monday.) We left and didnt think much of it her car is white so the scratch isnt as noticeable as it would be on a darker car. She just called me and said she was mad at how my husband acted she thought he was cocky. Then said if the roles were reversed what would we do. Well we have a brand new car so of course we would get it fixed we have full coverage but would have to pay the deductable. From the sounds of it she wants us to pay her 500 dedutable to get the scratch fixed. She doesnt even know if she has plpd or full coverage on her car. So i said call your insurance company in the morning and i would talk to my husband and we would go from there. My husband said no way is he paying to get her car fixed. We will pay for a new mirro but that is it. We dont have 500 dollars to give her our budget is very very tight right now. he says its her fault for freaking out when she tried to jump onto her lap and i had told her she would try. Do you think we are resonsable for the damages?? 

LJsMomma --- 14 years ago -

I told her i would just come and pick up our dog tonight and we would take her to the kennel while we are gone. She said no she loves our dog and wants to keep watching her but i am worried after she talks to my husband tomorrow things are going to get worse. 

Maui Girl (Mod) --- 14 years ago -

LJsMomma, I think you gave her proper warning. She sounds like she's being pretty crappy about it, and it's really her own fault for not taking your warning to heart. If I was in HER position, I'd feel like a retard for freaking out so badly because a dog jumped in my lap after his owners told me that might happen.

I HAVE (don't laugh too hard, guys) side swiped a friend's mirror off their car when I borrowed their vehicle once. I parked next to a pole, and TOTALLY forgot it was there when backing out, and totally scraped up the side, knocking the mirror off. I paid for the mirror replacement ($40 on Amazon, I think), and my gf and her husband didn't even give a rip about the scratches and dent. Her hubby popped the dent right out, and they magic eraser'd the majority of the scratches almost completely off. They hated that car anyway, and it was dented and scratched up beyond repair in other areas anyway, so the fact that I'd done that to their car turned into a huge joke between us, and they will never let me live it down (nor will I ever get to borrow their car again, but I don't blame them for that one! Lol).

The simple facts are this: She was driving the car. She offered to watch your dog. SHE decided to take your pet on a car ride, when she could have left him at home. She has fair warning of this animal's tendencies while in a vehicle. If this kind of thing went to court, you'd win. Hands down. She has no warrant to her case, and the fact that she's trying to blame you guys for her lack of skill in an unexpected distraction while behind the wheel isn't fair. I think you've both been more than nice in replacing her mirror. 

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

You gave her proper warning about the dog. I say it is not even your responsibility to pay for it. She knew what may happen and freaked out! But being a nice person maybe would pay for the mirror replacement and that is all. NOT a 500$ deductible! No way! Sorry, but she knew and it was her fault! I would be afraid to leave the dog there. Things could get worse from here as most people are crappy, but then again, she may not. 

Pandaroni --- 14 years ago -

take it to Judge Judy! lol Just kidding! But that would be a great episode! 

HeatherLynn --- 14 years ago -

You gave her a FAIR WARNING and she wanted to watch your dog... I would definitely not leave your dog with her now! lol. I would find another pet sitter or something, there's no way.

She took the risk and decided to drive with the dog knowing what she was capable of jumping into her lap lol. I agree with your husband, DO NOT pay the $500, who knows if she is actually turning it over to her insurance, if she really has an older car.... her car is probably not worth THAT much? lol. Just buy her some paint LMAO 

HeatherLynn --- 14 years ago -

I agree with Pandaroni! 

ShamWow --- 14 years ago -

Anyone that takes a ride with a pet in their car without them in a kennel is at fault for any damage done to their car while driving, regardless if the pet jumped on her or not she should have either restrained or not taken the pet with her. I can't tell you how many drivers I see riding around with a dog on their lap or worse, on top of the arm they are steering with. It's not your fault that she decided to drive with the dog in the car. 

Leesah --- 14 years ago -

I so agree with everything that has been stated! 

Shelley S --- 14 years ago -

I think you have done enough, you warned her, she spooked, not your fault. You didn't HAVE to fix what you have done so far, legally anyway, but morally I see why you did and I would have done the same. She sounds sincere in wanting to watch your fur baby, however not sure how I would feel about leaving it with her and her feel like we owe her more money because of her own fault, kwim? 

BelleAdoresMommaFriend --- 14 years ago -

Yeah, I think you have done plenty in this situation. The fault is entirely on her so the fact that you offered to do anything is a lot.

Just be nice and offer to help with what you already have and maybe the magic erase thing too if you can get one. But 500 for her own fault is a lot. 

Open Paws Pet Sitter --- 14 years ago -

Pet sitting, whether it be professonal or just being nice and helping someone out ISN'T as easy as people think :) You forewarned your friend and it was HER responsibility to secure the invironment and because of HER negligence HER deductable is exactly that ... HERS! Of course in good favor your husband fixed the mirror but it was HER NEGLIGENCE .....


END OF STORY 

Misty P. --- 14 years ago -

You need to get your dog back asap...sounds to me like she might be trying to keep it till you agree to pay something....just a thought 

Open Paws Pet Sitter --- 14 years ago -

@Misty P. my husband even said "I won't be shocked even if she says, I was NEVER warned" ... 

AwesomeSauce --- 14 years ago -

You gave her fair warning, she chose to drive with the dog in the car anyway. I agree with replacing her mirror out of courtesy, but that's it. I also wouldn't leave the dog with her. She ignored your warning, causing the mess to begin with. I wouldn't trust her not to do something else I may have warned her about. 

Irishgirl --- 14 years ago -

You need to get your dog back asap...sounds to me like she might be trying to keep it till you agree to pay something....just a thought 

 

33Whisky --- 14 years ago -

Agreed on getting your dog back ASAP.

The damage is not your fault, you warned her, she knew better and should have put the dog in the back and/or tethered your dog so as not to be able to get into her lap.

Find someone else to watch your dog, and tell her that any further repair is her choice and her expense.

Worst Case:
She hauls you to small claims court and ends up getting a ticket herself for admitting carelessness/recklessness behind the wheel despite prior knowledge of the risk.

Not your fault, not your bill, nothing you could have done to prevent it past warning her, and her stubbornness and deciding not to heed your warning is her own problem, not yours. 

Brenda E --- 14 years ago -

Does open paws have an FB page? what does she charge and has anyone here used her before?? 

33Whisky --- 14 years ago -

Also, do you and she live on post?

If she pursues this, go to the Mp's and/or Jag and discuss it with them, get their advice if she badgers you. 

HeatherLynn --- 14 years ago -

Brenda- yes she has a fb page, she is awesome we loved her! She watched our pups for about a week during Christmas. Just search open paws dog sitter on fb :) 

jden --- 14 years ago -

When backing up nobody including ubstructions or illegally parked vehicle etc can be at fault if you she was in motion and hit a stationary object. Without starting a war with a neighbor I would explain to her that it was her decission to have the pup in the car and that you were willing to go above and beyond to help her in return - HOWEVER, you under no obligation legally to pay for her damages or her inability to handle an obstacle properly. Jag will tell her the same as will her own insurnce compnay, they may call you for a statement - but do not give her money. The insurance company will deem you not at fault. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground