Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

in-laws?

who's talking here?

ella ella 1
details 1
AwesomeSauce 1
Samba 1
SouthernJ 2
OnARoll 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

SouthernJ --- 13 years ago -

ugggh, i really just need to rant/the opinion of a neutral party.
we are being stationed closer to my husbands family, about an hour away from his hometown. this is fantastic, because his parents are amazing grandparents. the problem is his sister.

she is 23, has dropped out of college twice, and lives in his parents basement. she's incredibly jealous of my husband, his career, and the attention that we get whenever we are around their parents. she has been mean and hateful to me since the day I married him. the last time we saw her was whenever she visited our home two years ago when our youngest son was born. she threw a HUGE tantrum because we wouldn't take her sight seeing the day after i gave birth, to the point that my MIL dropped everything and took her sight seeing as soon as it happened. i was livid at her, at the disrespect she showed my husband, and my husband was as well. he and i have not had a relationship with her since.

we really want to be close with his parents. our kids adore them and they are fantastic grandparents. we just can't be around her, and don't want our kids around her. we have suggested that they encourage her to become more independent (they pay her health insurance, have bought her three cars, give her gas money, pay her cell phone bill, and wake her up for work!). She insists that "she is independent, we just don't see it". It's maddening. And his parents, as sweet as they are, aren't willing to do that because his mom likes being "needed" and still playing the role of a parent with her.

On top of everything, I feel like we are owed some sort of an apology for how she behaved in our home. She talked awful to my husband, slammed doors, and stressed me out right after having a baby. I don't think expecting someone to apologize for that is unreasonable, is it?

Basically...am I alone in my frustrations? How would you handle things? My husband tried calling and talking to her last night and she was offensive, disrespectful, and refused to accept any responsibility for her actions. She, as always, blames me for us not having a relationship and says rotten things about me.

Deep down, my husband and I just want everyone to get along and to be close to his parents but she is preventing that. we feel like we can't even visit their home and enjoy living close to them because she is there and can't seem to act right. 

AwesomeSauce --- 13 years ago -

That behavior isn't right. I would say invite them to your home rather than visit there, and make the rules and expectations known. If she can't be respectful and well behaved, then she isn't welcome until she can be. You control who is in your home, and how you are treated. If she misbehaves while visiting at his parents' home, be clear about how her behavior makes you both feel, and leave.

My youngest sister lived with us for a while, and I eventually had to ask her to find a new place as she was not following the "house expectations" we set at the time she moved in. No hard feelings, just not willing to accept her behavior under my roof.

Good luck! I hope she grows up. 

details --- 13 years ago -

OMG I could write a book on in-laws.

She insists that "she is independent, we just don't see it".
I'm not trying to take their side, but this is entirely possible. She lives in their house, you don't. There are always two sides to every story and things are not always what they seem. I'd let this one go.

And his parents, as sweet as they are, aren't willing to do that because his mom likes being "needed" and still playing the role of a parent with her.
Truthfully I'd leave this issue alone too. Your MIL is still her Mom and if she wants to continue to parent her adult daughter like a child, that's her business. It might not be right, but it's her choice. Pushing this issue might really backfire.

On top of everything, I feel like we are owed some sort of an apology for how she behaved in our home. She talked awful to my husband, slammed doors, and stressed me out right after having a baby. I don't think expecting someone to apologize for that is unreasonable, is it?
Nope, not unreasonable at all but don't hold your breath for that apology. Although I will say my MIL just recently apologized for some atrocious things she did nearly three years ago, so there's always hope!

Basically...am I alone in my frustrations? How would you handle things?
You are not at all alone. I have had my fair share of in-law issues myself. I won't go into details but at this point we do not have a relationship with the ones who cause the issues. We also would like everyone to get along and be close, but you have to stop thinking that you can force that to happen. Have you seen Real Housewives of NJ? I have to admit your story kind of reminds me of Joe and Teresa lol!

In our case it's better that we don't have a relationship with the troublesome ones right now. If we have to be in the same place as them we are always polite but try to avoid any drama by talking to them as little as possible. In my opinion the SIL needs to grow up and come to the realization that if she wants a relationship with you and your family, she has to make the effort. I would personally not call her or have any contact with her until she figures that out. It might be hard (and silly) but I would only go over to the parents house when she's not there or arrange for them to come to your house once you're living there. Good luck! 

SouthernJ --- 13 years ago -

Thank you both for your advice. I REALLY wanted a different relationship for all of us. I really want my kids to be close to everyone and there to be no issues. I think I have to stop pushing for there to be some type of resolution and accept things the way that they are.

We had planned on staying at his parents during our PCS while my husband has leave (they haven't seen the kids in a year and are so excited about us moving back they made my husband's old bedroom into a special room for our kids...even going so far as to get a crib for the youngest and a bed for the oldest with bedding and the whole shebang...they really are sweethearts), but that probably isn't the best idea considering the circumstances with his sister. 

ella ella --- 13 years ago -

Sounds like my husbands cousin, we are living with his family while he is deployed, and oh boy she is one psycho.

She makes horrible accusation against me all the time, she will not even sit on the same couch as me, she walks in the house doesnt even say hi.


I have learned to make fun of it and ignore her, even with my many wanting times to tell her off. 

Samba --- 13 years ago -

In-laws suck AND suck you dry if you allow them to, AND try to rule your entire move, AND feel you owe them EVERYTHING! Oh wait..this was my story not yours! lol ;) You see how I feel? Not a very positive outlook of any of mine! 

OnARoll --- 13 years ago -

you will be an hour away. use that as an excuse any time you need one. but holidays? do you have other family you could visit? I would say invite them to your home rather than visit there
i totally agree. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground