Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Andrea Yates.....

who's talking here?

Frankie 1
Katena 3
Sandra 6
Merktdawg072 4
details 2
myopinion 12
AwesomeSauce 2
Your Mom 8

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

Not to start an argument, and I'd appreciate we all respect each other's opinions. I know a few of you may not know who she is but I do believe at least half of us do know. Last night I was watching a documentary series on CNN 'Crimes of the Century' and that particular episode was on Andrea Yates. Just curious how you guys feel about her and her husband and the trial and aftermath of it all. If you have Comcast, it is now on demand, if you don't, I don't think it's available online, sorry! Thanks for your opinions! 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

My heart breaks when I hear her name and reminded of her poor babies. I was young when this happened so just a few refresher questions, wasn't her husband aware she was...unstable yet left her alone with them? Didn't he get into trouble also? I remember bits and pieces and I remember she this happened but I was a freshmen in high school. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

Yes, they were the type of people that believed to have as many kids as God gave them, so when the incident happened her boys were 7,5,3,2 and the baby girl 6 months. After the 4th she suffered postpartum psychosis and was told she shouldn't have babies, but w/ meds she got better and they decided to have more but that required her to stop meds. She had attempted suicide twice, because she felt the need to harm the kids but didn't want to so tried to harm herself instead. His mom would come help but there was a 1 to 2 hour lapse between the time he went to work and the time she came. Now mind you, they were of the mentality of simplicity, therefore they lived in a trailer, then a bus for a while, he worked while she stayed home to homeschool and wash cloth diapers and look after many children all day long. He unfortunately didn't get into trouble even though I felt he was partly to blame since he knew how sick she was, she had been hospitalized just 2 days before this happened. He does feel he forgives her but cannot live with her because of what she did so he divorced her, remarried, went on to have another kid while she sits in a mental hospital for the rest of her life. Yeah, that pisses me off. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

If you have cable, you should see the documentary, it's really good. I've always felt the same way, I was outraged when she was found guilty of capital murder, thankfully she was given a second trial and was found not guilty by reason of insanity. I feel he is very responsible for this, unfortunately he didn't commit a crime LEGALLY. And her docs, well yeah, they don't deserve to be called that. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

I felt terrible for her. She was mentally ill and no one intervened. Very tragic. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

she is not a victim. no one is putting charlie manson in an institution and he is not mentally stable. is personal responsibility an archaic concept? 

AwesomeSauce --- 13 years ago -

I haven't watched this. Ill have to I think. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

Even if my husband was sick I don't think I could stay married to him if he did that to our children. I think he should be punished. He put those kids in harms way leaving them with her. So very sad. I'm glad she's in the hospital where she can't do this again. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

What's the documentary called?? 

details --- 13 years ago -

is personal responsibility an archaic concept? 

Yes! Most kids these days have no idea what it means.

But in the case of Andrea Yates I think she wound up where she belongs. As did Charles Manson. Charles Manson had a pretty troubled past and maybe if someone had intervened earlier in his life things would've been different for him too. Society has come a long way in dealing with mental health issues but we still have a long way to go. I also think the husband in Andrea Yates case should've held some responsibility. Her mental issues were well documented and long standing, and I don't think he should've been allowed to walk away from that the way he did. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Why I bother. We just did a case study on a female who was similar. Thank God her jury did not come from LU lol. She will be spending life in a mental health facility, medicated and with access to treatment. Thank God for the professionals, the rest is just squaky opinion on TV shows. 

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

Her mental issues were well documented and long standing, and I don't think he should've been allowed to walk away from that the way he did.

Definitely agree. He knew and I feel as though he is pretty guilty himself. Mental disorders should never be taken lightly. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

What's the documentary called??

Crimes of the century, if you have on demand go to tv shows, then shows A-C, then Crimes of the Century and it will be under CC 7/21(yesterday's date). I don't mean to break it down Mickey Mouse style but some shows are hard to find! 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

Mental disorders should never be taken lightly.

Agreed! This poor woman was not evil! She loved her children, but voices told her they would be serial killers and evil people and they would be better off dead. She was not making sense for days after this happened, she was seriously ill. I feel bad that now that she is treated she has to deal w/ what she did. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Agreed^^^^^^^^^^^^. And LIKE! 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

Thank God her jury did not come from LU lol.
she admitted to murder. aww but she had things going against her. poor lady. she had a difficult family. she took pills. she didn't know what else to do. the poor thing.
she makes quilts for God's sake! and APRONS! she misses her kids i bet. she has mental problems so lets take her as a project and fix the broken lady. it would be so interesting if we could all just FIX her.


if intervention WORKS before a crime happens then that is a success. if someone is thinking of harming their kids they can bring them to a fire station or hospital and leave. worst case scenario they walk away with no blood on their hands.

these are here for a reason

grandparents or family members are usually good custodians 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Ona.
I have a mentally ill son. I work and school in the psychology field.
To sum it up its people with your opinion that haunt our progress. Now I rarely get emotional here, but I beg you to really explore what your saying. Maybe you don't even realize. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Google can't teach us every thing. This is what personal experience and education can bring, that the Google can't. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

i have nothing against your son. but there has to be some black and white. if i were losing my mind and felt like harming someone i would walk away in a heartbeat. now if i didn't believe in personal responsibility and i felt strong feelings and started hearing voices i would be a danger to others. but it is my belief in personal responsibility that would shelter those around me that i love.

and i have felt this way before the invention of google. you assume that just because i google sources to answer questions that other people have answered that i take the internet as some sort of bible. this is not the case. i knew about the safe haven laws before i found the specifics online. seriously why do you hate google so much? just because someone has abused it in the past? 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Ona
When your mentally ill, depending on the type, you don't always know you are. You wouldn't have the capabilities to walk away. Shame on those that were her "support". Shame. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Ona
My son medicated and engaged in behavior mod therapy, is a safe happy child. If he's not medicated and in mod therapy........well that's not an option. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

well here are my mental issues that i am aware of: fear of intimacy combined with the fear of being alone. quite a conundrum. and guess what? because i have realized my root issues i am finding ways of overcoming them and healing. i take a rational, logical approach. fear leads to feelings of anxiety, but anxiety is not my root problem. those fears are. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

And that's a reflection of good mental health Ona. Good. But Yates, and people like my son don't have that ability. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

she had the ability to walk away. she was methodical. meaning she had some ability to process information. she knew there were consequences. she knew that before during and after. postpartum depression is a hormonal disorder. she was on pills. so did the medications work? 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Agree to disagree. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

in a world of blurred lines, and fifty shades of grey- a world where the literal north on a compass is constantly changing, i understand that not everyone will agree with each other. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

And they call it philosophy. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

No they call it social science. I have a hard time with that, and its my field of study. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

Buddhism is philosophy. Science is studying premises and trying to prove them. 

Katena --- 13 years ago -

This was a sad case. I hate it that men in general get to just walk away. She needed help and did not receive it. H e gets to go on with his life. I am a mother and suffered from post partum with my 3rd son. It was hard I never suffered again. We need to help our mentally ill not condemned them. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground