Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Open post?

who's talking here?

Misty P. 4
Amy L 4
Frankie 3
Merktdawg072 18
Shelley S 8
details 2
AwesomeSauce 1
VolsChick 5
txgirl1210 1
Your Mom 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

I'm curious on everyone's thoughts on this. We are currently stationed at Ft. Bliss. It's considered an open post, meaning anyone and everyone with a government issued Id can access post. Now, you do have to show your military id at the px and comm, but everything else is open to the general public...gyms, pools, parks and play grounds. Museums, the movie theater, and the super nice shopping center. I also just found out that the public can take part in MWR sports! (No wonder I can never get my son in!) now, keep in mind we live on the border of Mexico meaning these folks have access to our installation also. Like today, I took my kids to the splash park, which has a 100 person capacity. Well, once "the general public" showed, those who had been there for the previous session had to leave...meaning us, a military family, had to leave a military funded play area so a family from MEXICO could play. A guess a few years ago, before bliss became an open post, some public pools and such wouldn't allow military families to enjoy the facilities so Ft. Bliss then decided to "bridge the gap" and welcome the public to use all our facilities, minus the px and commissary. Now, come August 7 the rules are changing and the public wont be allowed to access the pools and gyms without an ID card holder. El Paso locals are pissed saying they have rights to post since military has access to their facilities. Thoughts? Sorry it's so long, but it makes me mad that our soldiers sacrifice so much and our privileges aren't privileges anymore if just anyone can take part. 

VolsChick --- 13 years ago -

First, not all hispanic families come from mexico, many are born right here with us. I understand the base trying to bridge the gap and work with the community. If you think about it we go to their communities and they feel as if we take their jobs and we aren't welcome, we cause landlords to raise rent because of bah and they feel the same way. You said it is open to anyone with a government Id can access it not illegals jumping the border. My husband deployed, was wounded in combat and I still don't feel like just because I have privelages means others should be excluded. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

I'm also Hispanic, so I'm aware that not everyone is from Mexico. If they have a drivers license they can come on post. With or without the Army I am a citizen of the us and can have access to any public facility of my choosing. However, IMO, a military post IS NOT public and should not be treated as such. Our soldiers work very hard and sacrifice a lot to have post privileges and I feel Ft Bliss is forgetting that. Our military posts should be taking care of their own before worrying about the community. When a city has a military post it creates jobs for the locals and adds to the economy. I am sorry, actually I'm not, my family gives up a lot, and I feel as though our families...yours and mine alike...is entitled to have privileges not provided to the general public, such as the commissary and px, or skies sports for our children. It's a perk among many other things that aren't so great being apart of the military. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

technically people could do that at our splash park too. they would just get a visitors pass. i'm sorry, but i'm not sure what you can do about overcrowding. it sounds sucky. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

Our splash park is enclosed and the door is watched by a life guard. The whole park (3 playgrounds and tables) is fenced in. It's not just the splash park. It's allowing civilians to come in and use EVERYTHING funded by MWR for soldiers and their Dependents. What really made me angry was the fact that locals can use sports and such. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

Also, the splash pad on Lewis doesn't have a capticity that would make it so you and your family would have to leave so civilians could have access. Tacoma has plenty of splash parks for civilians. 

AwesomeSauce --- 13 years ago -

I dunno. Ft Polk was an open post, in the sense that you could get on with just a license, no base tags or milID. Shopping on base required ID and the gym required a milID holding sponsor. Overcrowding is frustrating, but i don't find it that odd. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

I think you guys are missing my point. It's not the over crowding. I get crowds happen. It's that people who should not have access to our privileges are taking up spaces that they shouldn't be allowed. Lewis also used to be an open post, but now only events are open to the public since most are sponsored by local businesses. Here anyone can do shopping tax free at our shopping center...just not the px or commissary unless signed in by a DoD card holder. This is where I get frustrated. Not because its crowded. 

details --- 13 years ago -

Sounds to me like they're just mad. They were offered these services and opportunities and now they're being taken away. Wouldn't you be mad too? 

Misty P. --- 13 years ago -

I get what you're saying....that's stupid that something funded by MWR is being used by civilians...that is not fair. Plus, I don't know if it's an issue, but I know open bases usually have problems with civilians trashing the bases. And with all the money cuts its not fair that civilians not military related are using up the funding. Oh and theft used to be a problem 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

i would be mad too! and i mean overcrowding DUE TO the civilians. however, again, i am not too sure what you can do about the issue. it sucks, like i said, but i'm sure that if you complained to someone you wouldn't be the first. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

Aw misty!! Thanks for understanding! Actually, bliss is pretty decent compared to the rest of the city. I just got off the phone with the hubby and he agrees too that its bs civilians are using something that is meant for Dependents of our military. I guess the open post policy was through our previous general...and we just had a change of command. Looks like the new general is making changes for the better. Sure, I understand that the civilians might be upset, however, there needs to be an understanding why the rules are what they are. The funding for these facilities is to be used for military and Dependents only. Onaduck, like I said, all of these facilities are gated and there is always staff working at the park or obviously at the front desk at the gyms and pools. They need to crack down and check for DoD identification. I am more understanding of the crowds if its fellow military using it, but when a civilian squeezes in and is taking a spot made for me or my children or other military members that's what is not ok. 

Misty P. --- 13 years ago -

It just seems like a security risk as well 

VolsChick --- 13 years ago -

To me imo it sounds as though you think you are better than civilians just because your husband is in the military. We didn't deploy, we are all equal and I think you may be forgetting that. Not all posts create jobs and not everyone qualifies for those job that become available. 

Misty P. --- 13 years ago -

I can see how it can come across as that...but look at it this way...say you raise money towards a program for your kids (as MWR does for the military)...and then your kids don't even get to use it because some other kids that have nothing to do with it get to use it up. 

Misty P. --- 13 years ago -

I don't think it was the job issues she was really talking about...she was saying that civilians get upset because the military dependents take their jobs 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

When it comes to things that the Army is supposed to provide for Dependents of those soldiers, yes, I feel as though we (you and me alike) are entitled to those benefits and not civilians. I am not better then civilians, as without my husband I am also one. However, the funding I am talking about is to be used for military and their families...that would be you and me! My husband deploys, leaves for trainings multiple times a year, pulls duty often more then once a week, so excuse me for thinking that my children are entitled to the privileges the military is supposed to offer them and their fellow military peers to make being a military family a little easier. My son looks forward to taking part in MWR activities but often at bliss slots of full, and come to find out today those activities are being taken up by civilians who have no military Affiliation at all. How is right to use funding that isn't intended for you? Like I said, bliss is now under new command and looks like it will now be moving in a better direction. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

I can see how it can come across as that...but look at it this way...say you raise money towards a program for your kids (as MWR does for the military)...and then your kids don't even get to use it because some other kids that have nothing to do with it get to use it up.

Exactly! 

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

If you are not a Military ID holder or a family member visiting, after some serious security check ins, then you should not be allowed on post, involved in activities using the money intended for Military families, enjoying a free concert, splash park, shopping, etc. If you want these things then go talk to Uncle Sam and sign on the dotted line. Out service members are having enough cuts and they shouldn't allow civilians to take away anything else. Do I feel like my husband is more entitled to these things, you're darn right I do. He is sacrificing his life while Serving this country..... No way should some greedy little person take advantage if things offered to him. 

VolsChick --- 13 years ago -

Please don't include me in thinking what you are entitled to. I as a military spouse do NOT ffeel entitled to anything. Until i strap on those boots and do the same thing my husband does im not entiltled to it. You don't know how the mwr gets their funding, civilians could be sponsoring for civilians to play. I volunteered for years with kids and there is a lot of organizations that raise money for one cause when it really goes to another. You are basically saying your kids are entitled to everything and civilian kids whose family may not be able to afford for their kids to do something shouldn't get anything. You don't know what other people's situations are or if they are military affiliated or not. Some of these kids can be born out of wedlock but a parent is in the service and moved. You also have to consider kids who families are divorced and should still be allowed to participate. Bottom line is stop judging everyone and ranking yourself higher than everyone else. 

VolsChick --- 13 years ago -

However I do feel as though military kids should have priority in registration and if there is spots left then it goes to everyone else. Is your MWR on bliss apart off the YMCA? We have a few bases that are like that where the mwr and YMCA and together and that might be another reason civilians can enjoy these activities to. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

mwr funding comes from the service charges at the px and commi. other places contribute, but that is our "tax" 

details --- 13 years ago -

mwr funding comes from the service charges at the px and commi. other places contribute, but that is our "tax" 

I'm confused? I thought the surcharge at the commissary goes towards remodeling and building new commissaries. Is there a surcharge at the PX?

I'm pretty sure MWR is funded from from AF and NAF funds, donations, and of course all the fees they charge for memberships, services, and activities.

What I meant by saying they're probably just mad is that they might not understand. Think about all the times people say silly things because they are just completely ignorant of how anything in the military works. Honestly if my husband wasn't in the Army anymore and I was offered the opportunity to use the on post facilities I would not, because I would feel like I was taking it away from a service member or their family. But ten years ago, before I knew better, I probably wouldn't have felt the same way. At least after August 7th you won't have to worry about it anymore. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

Volschick, if your husband is serving then yes, his family is indeed entitled to this activities. Some MWR events get sponsored by outside business and such and that is the only time civilians should be allowed to par take in the event. By enrolling my kids in activities through the MWR or other wise on post, I am doing so for them to be around others in their same situation. Having a parent gone over seas, training, working late ect. If a law firm raises money for programs for their law firm families you would expect to be allowed to get involved so what's the difference?? 

Shelley S --- 13 years ago -

I haven't had any coffee yet and need to go back and read, but wanted to throw out there that here at Sill, I would say a good 60% of the volunteers who raise money to go toward MWR are civilians. For instance, soda and beer sales at our latest concert I worked with mostly civilians who had no connection to the post short of them just wanting to volunteer.

Like I said, I will go back and re read the thread to make sure I understand. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

I understand that if civilians are working events such as concerts, freedom feat ect that they should be welcomed to join in. Most of those bigger events are sponsored by local businesses. But when it comes to sports or the like it should be limited to military. 

Shelley S --- 13 years ago -

Should civilian coaches be able to allow their kids to be in the same sports they coach? Honest question, not arguing I swear :)

Me personally I would be ok with the situation I just asked about since they are contributing by coaching.

As for the other things, gyms, pools, etc I think it should be limited to dod and their families, maybe allowing a guest who isn't. On a limited scale of course. 

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

Majority of coaches on post for the MWR are parents that have volunteered. At least that's how it has been at most places we've been stationed. 

Shelley S --- 13 years ago -

Ah ok, wasn't sure, been forever since mine were in sports. 

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

Our daughters T-ball coach was a Soldier and his wife was the assistant coach. Oh and the other parents, my husband included, stayed at the bases to help the little kids out in knowing where to go next. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground