Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Ooo this might be a doozy. Let the debate begin.

who's talking here?

Frankie 9
Sandra 10
Merktdawg072 5
Megan LeeAnne 1
Maui Girl 2
Brenda E 2
Leesah 5
Shelley S 3
details 4
myopinion 6
CSGray 1
Alyyy 4
txgirl1210 1
Your Mom 14

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

So here lately a lot about people being here illegally has been brought to my attention. This whole making them legal thing they are trying to pass is really getting to me. Why are they doing something good for law breakers? I've heard they are sending more to do boarder patrol, which is awesome. I've met some Hispanic friends here and they have told me how, friends and family, have worked the system. Man, I was shocked!

Without being rude, name calling, or whatever you crazy ladies do sometimes, lol ;-), what do you think? 

Shelley S --- 13 years ago -

I think it's pure BS! 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

It's so frustrating!! Being here in El Paso, while is right on the border is still America. When I was working in a doctors office here I saw a lot of Hispanic patients and was always told I need to learn Spanish to respect their people (I am one of their people, I just don't look it) and even one patient was upset because one of our doctors in Filipina and said she shouldn't a doctor, it should be another Mexican!! A lot of people from over the border come here to work and take all the money home to the other side. Makes me angry because that's a job a citizen of this country could be working. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

I honestly believe it is the very best way to purchase more votes for oneself.
"Heyyyy I got you this, now do me a solid and VOTE for me."

Someone told me that US citizens can vote in Germany if they choose to pay their hefty tax. Now, I don't agree with all German policies, but can you imagine if we had a similar system here?

if you pay you have a say. 

details --- 13 years ago -

What is it they're trying to do? We haven't watched the news much since the Zimmerman trial ended.

Hubby and I have talked about immigration issues a lot in the past. We both think the federal government should set a date and then give them all a grace period to get legal. Like maybe six months. They could hire people to help get the paperwork processed faster, which would create jobs at least temporarily. We think they should have to pay a penalty out of their tax returns for a few years if they've been here illegally. And if they don't comply, they get deported, along with their family if they are here illegally too. No more of this having babies here so they can stay stuff. No more of this come here to go to school on the American taxpayer's dime and never leave, but also never pay taxes stuff. We also think there should be strictly enforced major fines and penalties (including mandatory jail time) for anyone caught employing illegals under the table. And I agree, most of the immigration laws are all a big dog and pony show just for votes. That needs to end. 

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

Can't pull up a article right now but look it up on CNN. This has been up for debate for a long long time. Pretty much trying to make the illegals legal. 

Alyyy --- 13 years ago -

You know there a lot of people here illegally from other countries not just Mexico, and alot of them aren't grouped into what a stereotypical illegal looks like which is Hispanic. And as I'm sure you know not all Latinos "work" the system. But i wouldnt be shocked by stories about it because citizens work the system everyday. Tons of them. Statistically white people are majority, African American in second and Hispanic and Asian are least. I am honestly so tired of hearing that we steal jobs. Please. When was the last time you wanted to work sixteen hour back breaking work days being paid one third of minimum wage with no benefits. And why does no one bring up the American business owners who rather hire an illegal over an American citizen. They are the ones at fault. Seriously, America is so greedy and feels so privileged it's offensive. 

Alyyy --- 13 years ago -

Also illegals DO pay taxes 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

When was the last time you wanted to work sixteen hour back breaking work days being paid one third of minimum wage with no benefits.

my husband was applying left and right and when he finally got a job as a janitor in otay mesa he was the minority and he got slandered and picked on and everyone was against him because he wasn't mexican. there were illegals working beside him and he didnt report them even though his father is border patrol. you know why? because it wouldn't make a difference if they got shipped 2 feet over the border-they would come back the next morning.
i believe with all my heart that HE was discriminated against. he is a hard worker. he has done back breaking labor for minimum wage. and guess what? we somehow lived on 900 a month without food stamps. we took rent, food and gas, cell phone and everything else out of that. we're as white as they come. i wont even use the term reverse racism. those that he dealt with trying to find work were straight up racist against him.

ps. sales tax doesn't count. 

Alyyy --- 13 years ago -

I don't really see how your comment is relevant to that quote. But yes racism exists. And yes lots of other races do back breaking work but as citizens expect at least minimum wage while illegals will work for less. Also it's less likely illegals will file lawsuits.

And obviously I didn't mean sales tax. Illegals work everywhere fast food places, markets you name it. And they pay taxes every year like everyone else. 

details --- 13 years ago -

OnADuck I'm sorry to hear about your husband's situation. My Dad went through something very similar when my parents moved to FL. Illegals DO steal jobs. It took my Dad (who had over 25 years of experience) forever to find a job in his field (construction). When he did get hired it was as a foreman of a crew and every single person on the crew was here illegally and being paid in cash, under the table. Once he realized this he quit, turned them in, and started his own business.

My Mom also works with people who are here illegally working in a school. They get fake SSN's. They are here, making the same amount of money as my Mom, and yes they are paying taxes. But they've also taken a job (a good paying one, with benefits) away from a citizen.

Also, if you look up the statistics, non-Hispanic whites no longer make up the majority of the population who are under the age of five. And yes, a portion of the people who are here illegally are not Hispanic, but Hispanics make up the majority of documented cases. I don't think anyone pointed this out to be negative about Hispanics, it's just a fact. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

By any chance did anyone see CNN's inside man on immigration???? Because a lot of what you guys are saying doesn't really happen! I was an illegal immigrant not by choice because I was a child, but having known illegal immigrants all my life these are the facts. We paid taxes, and no, not sales taxes, yet we were entitled to NO benefits from the government. No food stamps or medicaid contrary to popular belief. Can people get around it? Well DUH, but not just Mexicans find ways to fool the system, all other races including whites do it too. And yes, the majority of federal aid recipients are white! Now, give them 6 mos. to become legal? And how? You can't just file to become legal, you have to be claimed by someone! When you are able to, it costs thousands of dollars. And even if they could, 6 months is nothing. Sometimes it takes longer than that after you file paperwork to even have them acknowledge they received your paperwork! My process took almost 18 months. I know someone who was claimed by her brother, and she's going on 11 years. I don't think they should give them ALL residency, but I think they should at least allow them a driver's license. They're gonna drive anyway, I'd prefer they at least pass a test that says they can. All you comcast folks, look for inside man on demand, it's very enlightening and true. This coming from someone who was once there and knows many. Most are not here saying 'hahaha I beat the system', most live in fear of being deported and separated from the families or thrown in jail. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

And quick question, when was the last time you met an American citizen who applied to work picking fruits and veggies? 

Leesah --- 13 years ago -

They do the work that most Americans feel like they are above. A decent amount of homeless people are homeless because that is the life they want. They make an okay living in the streets asking for money, so that is their 'job'. I worked with a lot of illegals in Texas, and they are pretty hard workers. They were also being paid under the table in cash, and paid no taxes though. I think we need to change up the system a little bit, but don't have any great ideas that would solve everything. If we excuse the current illegals in our country (no matter the race), we are sending a very strong message that it is okay to break the law and do what you want. If the US eases up the VISA process, we would have huge a problem with immigrants wiling to work for lower wages and taking jobs away from Americans that expect better. Every route is a win/lose situation. 

details --- 13 years ago -

And quick question, when was the last time you met an American citizen who applied to work picking fruits and veggies?

I actually have a friend who does this, in Vermont, on an organic farm. She makes minimum wage and absolutely loves her job.

The problem is not all on the people who come here illegally. That's why we (meaning hubby and I) think they (meaning the fed) should change it. Give them an opportunity to become citizens, in a timely low-cost manner. Make the immigration process easier to begin with, for everyone, but start with the ones who are here already.

I have to wonder, if it's so hard to be here as an illegal immigrant, then why do so many of them come at all? 

Shelley S --- 13 years ago -

I think we need to change up the system a little bit, but don't have any great ideas that would solve everything. If we excuse the current illegals in our country (no matter the race), we are sending a very strong message that it is okay to break the law and do what you want. If the US eases up the VISA process, we would have huge a problem with immigrants wiling to work for lower wages and taking jobs away from Americans that expect better. Every route is a win/lose situation.

Very well said! 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

I have to wonder, if it's so hard to be here as an illegal immigrant, then why do so many of them come at all?

Because they don't have jobs in a country with a corrupt government. Most don't come to become citizens, mostly they want work to feed their families and live a better life. Also, before anyone says 'they have babies here so that the babies can give them papers'. NO! I think they have to be either 18 or 21 to claim parents. 

Merktdawg072 --- 13 years ago -

They are working for less then minimum wage because they are still making more then they would in their own country. And what DETAILS said, if its so rough for them to be here, why break the law and be here? Go work on making your own country better. 

Leesah --- 13 years ago -

Mexico is a rough country to live in, their government is a lot more corrupt than ours is. Incidents where 40 people are beheaded and left in the road to send a message, are a pretty common thing down there. As a compassionate human being, I totally understand the need/want to be safe, and be able to feed and cloth your family. I think we all know it's a lot harder to just go better ones country...
I really wish there weren't so many illegals in our country, and that they had a better option than sneaking in, but it is what it is. I can't see anyone fixing this situation, other than drastically changing the US for the worse, for a very long time.
I think what needs to be done now is keep more people from being able to get in. I don't see anything wrong with being deported for breaking the law, it is what it is. If they have children, they should be allowed to take their kids with them, or leave them for adoption. Their choice. I think every illegal immigrant already know that is what they are risking anyway. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

And quick question, when was the last time you met an American citizen who applied to work picking fruits and veggies? 
my husband did.

i think that those who need to escape from a bad situation should gain legal asylum, not citizenship without working for it. the people who came to this country worked for their citizenship. i'm even talking about the native americans who gave back to the land when they traveled through for the first time.
i support every law that provides legal asylum. 

details --- 13 years ago -

Also, before anyone says 'they have babies here so that the babies can give them papers'. NO! I think they have to be either 18 or 21 to claim parents. 

I don't know what the law is, but I don't think this is why they have babies here. I think they have babies here for the same reason citizens have babies...either they want one or, ya know, it just happens lol. I do think, however, that the amendment needs to be amended because clearly we're at a point in history where it causes an issue.

Hubby and I talk about this a lot. I often wonder if we will ever see a true resolution to the immigration issue in our lifetime, and most of me thinks probably not. But then again I also never really believed we'd see gays openly serving or women in combat so who knows! 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

i'm not a racist by any means. i don't think either dems or repubs have the solution. obviously there are needs. have you ever looked into how hard it is to emigrate to another country? you have to have a job lined up or get one within 6 months of arrival. here though too many people are just turning a blind eye because that is the only option that is provided to them.
you know how discouraging the new proposals for citizenship are to those who fought tooth and nail to do things by the books? no wonder patriotism is dying. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

I don't know what the law is, but I don't think this is why they have babies here

Believe it or not I've heard this more than once! 

CSGray --- 13 years ago -

When was the last time you wanted to work sixteen hour back breaking work days being paid one third of minimum wage with no benefits.
Been there. Done that... At least I got paid something... oh..and I'm very white... 

Shelley S --- 13 years ago -

Believe it or not I've heard this more than once!

I have heard of this as well 

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

Just now catching up. Going somewhat better than I thought it would.

Seriously, America is so greedy and feels so privileged it's offensive.

Alyyy, if this comes off as rude I apologize in advance. It's typing so you can't really tell what my tone, facial features, and body language is. Seeing how you live in America I wouldn't be so quick to say this. Not everyone is this way but when you feel like you've been taken advantage of, I can totally see how it can seem that way.

Heck I don't like anyone that works the system regardless if you're white, brown, black, or neon green. I see no color when it comes to people, just the good and the bad. If you are breaking the law, working the system, illegal (regardless of what country you came from, even Canada) then you are a law breaker. I feel anyone using government assistance should take a drug test and have background check. Nothing should just be handed to anyone.

I'm sorry if using Hispanics as my topic of choice offended you but talking to our friends (who are both Hispanic) brought the conversation up. They are mad that their own family members aren't doing it the right way and how much they take advantage of things. They told me how they do it all and get away with it and to me that's awful.I get why they do it, for the better life, but there is a right way and a wrong way.

I think it hits close to home when people say Americans aren't willing to do hard labor. No, that's pretty much a lie. Some Americans, not all, were fired, my Dad included, from jobs because they figured out they could hire in immigrants (legal and illegal) to work for cheaper. My Dads boss was from Guatemala and she was legal but 90% of the others were not. She told my Dad how they worked the system. It's kinda sad. The only ones I feel bad for are the children who have no choice in the matter. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

My Ex's sister married a illegal and moved to Hildago Mexico. But made sure to come back and have four kids and went over again. They have a diary farm. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

america has become so us vs them. it hasn't always been this way. there have been other periods in history of race wars, but i think we should learn from history this time around instead of repeating it. 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Stupid auto correct 

myopinion --- 13 years ago -

Yeah that's right they have a diary farm. They farm diarys. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground