Lewis Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Lewis bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore Fort Lewis housing courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Debate time.............

who's talking here?

Frankie 3
Sandra 6
Megan LeeAnne 2
ferrisgirl5 1
Shelley S 2
details 1
CSGray 2
AwesomeSauce 1
MOproblems 2
Your Mom 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

Would you consider a veteran someone who has served and was discharged honorably or retired OR any of the above including active duty serving at this time???? 

details --- 13 years ago -

Yes to all. There is some quote (I don't know who said it and I'm totally paraphrasing because I don't remember exactly how it goes) about a veteran being a person who at one point in time signed a blank check for their life to our country. That pretty much sums up how I feel. 

MOproblems --- 13 years ago -

I thought I understood that it was anyone who was ever in the service. 

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

Anyone that has served for any length of time 

Shelley S --- 13 years ago -

Veterans by definition yes, did they serve honorably, well that's the big question... 

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

^ definitely agree there. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

Then where in the world did this person I speak to say that it was someone who HAD served?! 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

Honestly, I feel weird calling my 19 yr old a veteran =/ 

Frankie --- 13 years ago -

I gotta say, and sorry for stepping on any toes, but I feel you are only a Veteran if you have been to war. I posted the definition of it but I don't fully agree with it. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

I gotta say, and sorry for stepping on any toes, but I feel you are only a Veteran if you have been to war. I posted the definition of it but I don't fully agree with it.


See I googled it under different things and it went both ways so that's why I brought it up here! 

Shelley S --- 13 years ago -

I feel weird calling my 26 year old that as well Sandra. He is currently serving in Afgan sandbox though, but still feels weird because all the men in my life before me (uncles and even my grandmother) all served. 

Megan LeeAnne --- 13 years ago -

My husband is currently in and my mom posted happy Veterans Day on his facebook last year. He didn't tell her but he questioned me...his exact words were...why would she put that? I'm not a veteran. 

Megan LeeAnne --- 13 years ago -

He's been deployed twice. I think he considers it as once your no longer active military. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

i think that someone who has been deployed feels like they "earned" being called a veteran, but i believe anyone who answered the call to possibly lay their life down at any given time should be called a veteran. and i'm pretty sure most places of businesses and organizations call you a veteran if you're day one at training, or even dishonorably discharged.

i think that there are people who do not, and never will belong in the military (I've known at least one of those) and even if that individual gets dishonorably discharged and loses some benefits, the truth of the matter is that he deployed and could have been KIA. sometimes people have mental disorders that don't get recognized till years down the road that could have been there since before enlistment. i consider even those who don't deserve all the benefits of being in the military a veteran if they ever committed to laying their life down if they obeyed orders.

i think the confusion lies with stereotype. you can use the term veteran to describe a veteran doctor-meaning very experienced.
when say the word veteran, at least for me world war 2 or vietnam usually are in the sentence. because that describes a unique individual.

we have so many descriptive words for all the other military personnel past and present. active dury, fuzz patches, career man, reservist, etc.

the history of veterans day is about recognizing all military personnel. 

CSGray --- 13 years ago -

If a person has served in a war zone as military personnel, they are a veteran, no matter if they are active duty, reserve, guard, retired, medically discharged, ETS'd, or even less than honorably discharged.
That is the definition of military veteran.
If someone was in the service, but never deployed to a combat zone, they are not a veteran. 

AwesomeSauce --- 13 years ago -

I discussed this with my husband last night actually. I had always thought it was anyone that served at one point, he basically said the same thing as CSGray. 

Your Mom --- 13 years ago -

i think there's a difference between military veteran and combat veteran... 

MOproblems --- 13 years ago -

Someone Google this and put it to bed. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

I did, got different answers and decided to bring it on here. 

Sandra --- 13 years ago -

i think there's a difference between military veteran and combat veteran.

agree! 

CSGray --- 13 years ago -

We (my husband and I) go by Combat Veteran as the definition.

Most military that I know do, including my late grandparents (both sets) 

ferrisgirl5 --- 13 years ago -

Thanking active duty on Veterans Day makes sense to me because they are serving and will be a veteran someday. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Lewis Underground